tintypes
by Douglas Messerli
Richard Brooks and John Huston
(screenplay, based on a play by Maxwell Anderson), John Huston (director) Key Largo / 1948
While passions and violence simmer inside the oppressively hot Key Largo
hotel, outside a hurricane begins to bluster, drawing the local Seminole
Indians and two escaped Indian prisoners, John and Tom Osceola, to the hotel
doors. Obviously, now that the cast has all come together, the tough talk can
begin and the fireworks set off.
Based on a poeticized play by
old-time wordsmith Maxwell Anderson, the highly revised script by Richard Books
and John Huston takes on various groups of actors, one by one, accommodating
each of their demands, needs, and emotions with Huston’s camera dutifully
following. What they say is fairly stereotypical, with Bogart, once again,
playing the disillusioned idealist, Robinson, the loud-mouthed gangster,
Barrymore the fearless liberal, Bacall the quiet and needy would-be lover, and
Trevor a drunken and abused ex-singer. The others serve as variations and
oppositions to these types. But that is part of the story’s theme: each of
these figures is caught, to some degree, within the limitations of his or her
human nature. They are figures trapped by their own stereotypical identities.
Given the stagey gimmickry of this wooden play, it is almost a wonder
that it remains watchable today. The acting, obviously, is what sets it apart
from the hundreds of Petrified Forest imitations
filed over the decades. Like his Rick of Casablanca
Bogart as McCloud, at first bowing out of any heroism, ultimately becomes the
hero by killing all of the bad guys, one by one, on a boat in which they are
trying to escape to Cuba. The Bacall character, despite having hardly any
lines, is, as always, so beautiful that she is destined to get her man.
Barrymore gets a chance to strut his stentorian voice, and Trevor to slur her
words. Most of the others are doomed to die. It is almost as if we are
witnessing an audition for various character types—but then, these are not just
ordinary actors, and that’s what makes this work, at times, crackle with energy
and radiant delight. Perhaps because we do know these actors so well and get to
watch them here so play to type, the movie, amazingly, comes alive.
Robinson, in particular, is moving—or we might say, pathetic—in his inabilities to perceive his limitations, refusing to accept the destructiveness of the growing storm outside the hotel windows or the larger “storm” of change churning up the world around him which has made his type a figure of the past, replacing it with somewhat more sinister forces that no longer offer the values of “protection,” “loyalty” and “courage.” One might even describe Huston’s version of Key Largo as a sort of dirge for a world that for a multitude of reasons (and excuses) could no longer exist.
And then, out of the blue, so to speak, Trevor/Gaye Dawn is asked to
sing one of her old torch songs. She refuses to do so without a drink, but
Robinson barks out another command. Slowly and unsurely, the actress begins
“’Moanin’ Low” a cappella, in a voice
that might once have been fairly sweet, as if crying out against the awful
situation in which the world as suddenly found itself entrapped.
Legend has it that Trevor believed the song would be dubbed, and kept
asking Huston to rehearse it, he assuring her there was still plenty of time
before the shoot. One day, however, he announced that it was time for the song,
and demanded that she perform it on the spot. If the song begins all right, the
tune soon goes off key, slows down, falters, and breaks off. It was a take!
Bogart, a gun pointed at his heart, goes to the bar, pours out a drink and
offers it to her: “You deserve this.” Trevor won an Oscar for Supporting
Actress for what one might describe Huston’s mean trick!
Still, I’ll surely watch Key Largo
next time it flickers across the television set.
Los Angeles, December 9, 2013
Reprinted in World Cinema Review (December 2013).
No comments:
Post a Comment