love, vodka, and guns
by Douglas Messerli
Andrey Zvyagintsev and Oleg Negin
(screenplay), Andrey Zvyagintsev (director) Левиафан (Leviathan) / 2014
That folk, particularly Nikolay (Kolya) (Aleksei Serebrayakov), who has
built the house himself, have lived in this spot for generations, and are
determined to remain there, despite the fact that for inexplicably petty
reasons, the local mayor, Vadim (Roman Madyanov)—behaving more like a Mafioso
figure than a public leader—has done everything in his power to get rid of of
Nikolay, his companion, and his young son, Roma (Sergey Pokhodaev). Although we
quickly recognize that the legal system is rigged so that Nikolay has little
chance of winning his case, he has, nonetheless, been able to stall the
proceedings, and is about to get one last hearing. He leaves his house in the
morning to pick up his Moscow lawyer and close friend, Dimitriy (Vladimir
Vdovichenkov) at the train station.
The tragedy of the “leviathans” is that even the great giants of the sea were outwitted and destroyed by the puny men surrounding them. So too is the large Russian populace at large unable to survive the petty lies, restrictions, and abuses of their few leaders.
While the close friendship between the
wily lawyer and his client should quickly result in a triumphant defeat of the
town’s blustering mayor, everything falls apart because of the oppositions’
petty interrelationships. Roma, a young boy with nothing to do and nowhere to
go (he spends most of his evenings sitting around a fire in a nearby ruin with
his friends, swigging down beer), is resentful of Lilya, who has attempted to
replace his recently dead mother. Dimitriy and Lilya, it appears, have long had
an intense relationship—which perhaps predated Kolya’s marital relationship
with her—which is suddenly reignited upon Dimitriy’s return to the town.
Although Kolya is clearly justified in his hatred of the town rulers, he is a
hothead who cannot restrain his behavior, making him an easy target for
criminal accusations. And in the end, it appears, there is not much difference,
in terms of their whoring and drunken violence, between the bullies and those
who are bullied by them.
The real reason for the day trip, possibly, is to provide yet another
occasion to drink. The central activity of these figures, in fact, appears to
be swigging down glasses (and sometimes whole bottles) of vodka as quickly as
possible, with only cigarette breaks in between. It is, indeed, a central
Russian pastime which I have witnessed firsthand (see My Year 2000). And it is, ultimately, what helps to turn their
justifiable rage against their selfish leaders into violent actions against one
another. When the young boys discover Dimitriy and Lilya making love in a
nearby isolated spot, Dimitriy turns on one of the boys, an act which, when
reported by another child, leads Nikolay to violently react, as he beats
Dimitriy and shames his wife.
Those actions, in turn, have serious ramifications. Vadim, kidnapping
Dimitriy, has his thugs beat him and engage in his mock murder to scare him
off. The scare works, in part, because Dimitriy is not the brave man he may
pretend to be—after all, his has a family back in Moscow who are now threatened
by his acts; but, just as importantly, he no longer has a reason to stay,
having destroyed his friendship with Kolya, and losing Lilya, who has returned
to her dead-end current relationship.
Subtly, and—given Putin’s current manipulation of truth with the promulgation of a series of determined distortions of reality, outright lies, and skillful mythmaking—amazingly, Zvyagintsev’s film reveals how the corrupt Russian government (like the Soviet system before it) works with the Russian Orthodox Church and numerous other tutelary systems to keep the people from even imagining what any truth might look like. But then, so Leviathan suggests, the people themselves help to assure their own blindness through the erratically independent, violent, alcoholic-fueled rage in which they stumble through life.
Yes, we in the U.S. are often equally misled by our various government
leaders, are often confused as to what might constitute the truth. But the
differences are notable. If in our country the corrupt most often bribe the
police to dissuade them from doing their
jobs, paying them to “look the other way,” in Russia, it appears, you have to
bribe the police to do their jobs. But then, the system of
justice, in Zvyagintsev’s world seems to be owned by the corrupt themselves. So
all hope becomes a kind of delusion. Is it any wonder that yet another swallow
of Vodka goes down so smoothly? It tastes better than the real truth—whatever
one might imagine that as being.
Los Angeles, January 6, 2015
Reprinted from World Cinema Review (January 2015).
No comments:
Post a Comment