Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Charles Chaplin | City Lights / 1931

a burlesque and a romance

by Douglas Messerli

 

Charles Chaplin (screenwriter and director) City Lights / 1931

 

I had not seen Charles Chaplin’s City Lights since my college days at the University of Wisconsin, and might not have watched it again before my death had it not, quite unexpectedly it seemed to me, wound up on two the major LGBTQ+ film lists, that broad-ranging list of films “Any and All LGBTQ+ Film”" compiled by Beryl Parkey on Letterboxd and Matthew Floyd’s more carefully curated list “Homosexuality in Pre-Stonewall Cinema” connected with Mubi.

     For those who have missed my previous explanations of how I gathered up the hundreds of titles reviewed in these pages, I repeat that when I began collecting titles for the all-inclusive My Queer Cinema volumes, I selected from various lists already in existence such as the two listed above as well as numerous others on the internet and elsewhere, from the several critical studies I’ve mentioned in my introductions, from my own history of cinema viewing and writing, and from personal suggestions of friends and acquaintances. No matter how doubtful I have been about certain titles I’ve found listed, I have been careful to revisit all films given the possibility that when I first saw these films I simply was not alert to the coded or minor LGBTQ characters and incidences.

      A substantial number of the titles I’ve found on various lists simply didn’t appear to me to be credibly representative of LGBTQ influence or even interest after seeing the films again. Although I have included many films that others have complained about as not containing LGBTQ material, I am convinced that given the carefulness with which I have approached all films that I can substantiate—at least to my satisfaction—my final choices. But it is my logical and careful analysis of each film that assures me of those I finally included. And, as I said, a great number of films seen by others to be of lesbian, gay, bi-sexual, transgender and/or transsexual interest simply did not pass the test.


     To my wonderment, City Lights most certainly did pass my queer test. How could I have missed such obvious gay allusions, I had to ask myself? Of course, I was young and maybe not even sexually out of the closet at the time I first saw this film. And I wasn’t looking primarily for gay content. Still, I spotted the gay content of great many films long before I was at work of these volumes and wrote fairly coherently about it. Indeed, the fact that I missed that content in one of Chaplin’s major works provides an excellent example, I now realize, of another way in which coding works in motion pictures.

    Many films, as I have argued elsewhere, are coded in a manner that the gay content works underneath the heterosexual narrative, hidden to those not looking for or not having the visual and verbal language to recognize the cues. In other films, however, the gay aspects are so openly exposed and function so nicely simultaneously with the normative heterosexual story that we simply don’t read them as being seriously queer and perceive them simply as oddities of plot or comic overstatements. In City Lights the central story, a romance, concerns the Tramp’s love for a blind flower seller (Virginia Cherrill) and the major plot is motivated by his attempts to demonstrate his love for her by helping her to financially survive and by paying her travels to a doctor who will cure her blindness, even if the cure might, in fact, ends their relationship when she discovers who he truly is. Nonetheless, the Tramp succeeds in accomplishing both her personal well-being and her eye surgery and cure.

      The problem is how to make his help credible, how to find a way to make a totally penniless street person find enough money in order to pay for his would-be lover’s needs. Obviously, one way is to simply put him to work. And at one point in the story that is precisely what the plot does, as he goes to work as a street cleaner with a few comic devices attached, including the appearance of a small herd of horses which he avoids following up his broom with and waste cannister only to be faced by an elephant. But to put the Tramp to work for too long a period would be to destroy is character. If the man can easily make money enough to pay his lover’s rent, than how can we justify his role in life, a down-and-out street person who simply cannot find employment. Chaplin makes sure that he is quickly fired.

      There is always a temporary job involving great dangers as in Modern Times, and for this film the writer and director calls up that world when the Tramp is encouraged to play at being a boxer, sharing the take with another boxer who will pretend to knock him out. Of course, in the Tramp’s world nothing goes as planned, and when the other boxer runs off, Chaplin’s character is forced to face a real boxer at great danger in a series of wonderfully pantomimed dances where the Tramp attempts to hide from the real thing behind the referee and attempts to outwit the other boxer with sudden hits like a pop-up jack-in-the-box. It works as humor, but his character again demands that he lose the bout. To win would turn the loser into an unidentifiable other being who is not in this film.

     And indeed, although both of these sequences have some memorable moments, they represent the weakest and least essential moments of the film. They simply make sure that he attempts to make other choices before the more direct approach he takes.

    The only way to truly find money, obviously, is to somehow get the character involved with a wealthy man who’s willing to give him the cash; and that takes a kind of relationship that is nearly impossible and totally illogical—although it happens in several of Chaplin’s films—given that the dirt of the street naturally corrodes the oil of wealth.

      In Chaplin’s clever thinking the dirty street person must be made interesting to the wealthy man in a proper tuxedo by introducing a situation straight out of burlesque, an accidental coupling of two men from completely different backgrounds who become something more than mere friends, despite the fact that that word will be used to officially designate their relationship.

     Indeed, the Tramp almost as often as he behaves as man who loves women is forced in order to survive to also play the courtier to powerful men. One of the first things Chaplin’s Tramp does when he faces trouble or men of violence is to play the weakling, a kind of sissy and a flirt, offering up, so it seems, his entire body as a form of amelioration.


     In City Lights he does precisely that when he meets up with the “real” boxer he is supposed to face in the ring, as he suddenly purses his mouth, blinks his eyes, and weaves his head in a posture of sexual enticement, almost begging the brute for just a little love. Indeed, he plays the sissy so successfully and the other boxer decides to undress for the bout behind a pulled curtain. Chaplin does this time and again throughout his films, suddenly turning coy and behaving in a sissified manner when challenged without an easy exit.



      In a world in which he is entirely dependent upon others, he seems to recognize that no matter what he does, those in power will have their way with him no whatever his personal desires. Accordingly, the Tramp becomes the great assimilator, a reality that Chaplin makes clear in the very first scene of the movie where even the public statues of Peace and Prosperity, about to be unveiled become just such a sexual force. Waking up on the lap of the female mother of the marble male statues to Peace and Prosperity, he is immediately jabbed in the ass by Prosperity with a raised sword. In short, he is publicly fucked, A moment later, when he escapes the sword, he is immediately rimmed by the same figure as his ass falls back upon the sculpture’s face before he winds up with his butt being goosed by Peace’s open hand. The pliable beggar has no choice but to be sexually available to all.



     He soon meets the drunken eccentric millionaire (Harry Myers) whose wife has evidently just left him. Feeling he has nothing left to live for, he attempts suicide in the melodramatic fashion of burlesque, placing a rope tied to a rock which he plans to throw into the ocean taking his own body with it. The kind and loving Tramp attempts to prevent it, nearly drowning himself in the process. But in that action of saving the man’s life he becomes this drunken rich man’s “best friend,” (a term now often used in gay films to suggest someone other than what it seems to suggest) as he hugs and kisses the Tramp with thanks, the two of them looking very much—even the policeman who encounters them hinting that he two sees them as such, two homosexuals hiding out of the dark pier to make out.

     The millionaire not only insists on taking his new friend out on an elaborate “date” to a night club wherein various comic disasters are enacted, but demands he come home to live with him, even offering him his car as he might lure a new girlfriend.


      With nowhere to really sleep and no will of his own, what can a Tramp do but to take advantage of the food, drink, and good times he’s being offered? The two quite naturally in this comical gay myth end up together in bed.


       The only necessary interruptions to this seemingly “perfect relationship” occur when the symbol of order and propriety, the man’s valet, will not full permit the friendship to blossom and when the wealthy man utterly forgets his odd “friend” the moment he becomes sober. This is the way the plot assures its ordinary viewers that it’s not really serious and that what you have just seen is a comic fluke. You might also argue that our eccentric millionaire was the original closeted gay type who continually argues after a night of gay sex, “I drank so much last night that I can’t remember a thing,” a figure who William Friedkin’s Boys in the Band know quite well.

      Fortunately, the eccentric millionaire doesn’t wait long to fill up with alcohol again and when he reencounters the Tramp takes him back into his arms, to a party, and to bed.

     No one in their right mind perceives this as a real sexual relationship. This is merely a comic burlesque-like routine that conveniently introduces our hero to a source of finances so that he might win over his true female love. And the comic relationship also must come to an end for the Tramp’s story to come to its logical close. At the very moment when the Tramp, handed a thousand dollars by his friend, is so joyful that he hugs and kisses his friend as the millionaire had previously done to him, the wealthy man pulls back in some disgust. And in just a few frames, the Tramp falls out of his good graces from being a bosom buddy—who, in fact, saves the millionaire from real thieves—to a position where all involved claim he is a robber who has stolen the money he intends to present to his blind love.

      Chaplin’s character escapes so that he might hand over the loot, but of necessity is arrested and imprisoned, the entire comic second “plot” having come to an end so that normative heterosexuality may prevail. The Tramp must pay for playing the “gay” man about town.

       By film’s end, full heterosexuality has been restored and his true love finally even recognized and possibly accepted, as the former blind woman recognizes the hands of the man who has helped her “to see,” including the reality she is now facing.

      Yet Chaplin wisely does not follow through with a reunion or even a heterosexual kiss. As a man of the streets, owned by everybody, to be recognized and taken in would be to destroy the man destined to live as an outsider, to turn him from the permanent figure of gentrified disgrace into someone of societal value and therefore end the life of Chaplin’s persona. If his comic homosexual adventure must end nowhere, so must his dramatic heterosexual fantasy, leaving him an asexual being waddling down the highway to his next series of adventures. If Charlie belongs to everybody, he must also belong to no one.

 

Los Angeles, January 14, 2023

Reprinted from World Cinema Review (January 2023).

 

 

Giorgos Katakouzinos | Άγγελος (Angelos) (Angel) / 1982

the angel brought down to earth by hate

by Douglas Messerli

 

Giorgos Katakouzinos (screenwriter and director) Άγγελος (Angelos) (Angel) / 1982

 

This Greek film of 1982 is a very difficult film to watch. And it took me a couple of days just to endure it. It moves about in search a various forms of love in so many different ways, portraying each of the quite fully and forcing us to attempt to comprehend, something we know to be impossible, why each individual has chosen to love who they have, most the relationships cruel and forbidding in this world of 1982 Greece when homosexuality, in particular was against the law, police regularly rounding up gay men in the parks where such sexual behavior occurred at night.

      In fact, the film begins with just such a raid, with dozens of police cars arriving at the Athens park and rounding up dozens of men having sex in the dark bushes. Some run into the public bathrooms, hoping to escape the police. It does them no good. Young men, older, and just gentlemen gawkers all are shoved into a police bus and brought to justice, which in that day meant even worse punishment through contacting the parents and exposing their homosexuality, which as in many such highly restrictive societies meant ostracization of the family as well and inner turmoil which often resulted in the young boys of 17 or slightly older being cast out of their hopes along with further violence.


     The 20 year old, stunningly handsome Angelos (Michalis Maniatis) is among those young men, although he escapes miraculously, encountering a darkly handsome and hirsute sailor Mihalis (Dionysis Xanthos) who points the best way out of he park and follows him to the train, finally demanding he have a drink with him.

      He pretends to be simply an admirer of the boy’s beauty, and forces him to promise a meet-up the next night at a local amusement park. But we know there is something deeper going on here, and we watch with expectation as they meet up in the park and actually enjoy an evening on the rides before they later meet up in “his” apartment, where even on his first meeting the innocent Angelos should have caught on that Mihalis is not a one-man guy. But the sweet sailor somehow convinces him that Angelos is now his only love, they have sex, and so begins this intensely darkening relationship.


    Earlier, we witness Angelos returning home to see his drunken father, underneath of whom is his no longer-loving mother (Katerina Helmy), a relationship quite clearly beyond repair. His sister is an invalid with a neck-brace, unable to move or speak. Yet it appears to be only her brother, who talks to her, comforts her, and later, we observe gently feeds her, and the bond between the two speaks of so much impossible love that it truly brings one to tears, particularly within a family that is so angry and hateful toward each other.

    By day, Angelos works in a jewelry shop where he polishes and engraves necklaces, bracelets and medallions. He is a good worker, and the owner is impressed with his abilities. A man (Giorgos Bartis) enters the shop, who we have noticed is utterly fascinated with Angelos, ordering a medallion to be engraved, in fact with Angel’s own name.

   We soon perceive that he is Angelos’ ex-lover and, although he clearly recognizes that their relationship is over and is now leaving the country, cannot bear to leave without one more encounter with Angelos. The boy promises to meet again with him, and does so, the man warning him against a relationship with Mihalis, who he claims is a known figure in the community.

    Without actually saying so, he is telling him that Mihalis is a fraud, actually a practiced pimp, slowly reeling the young Angelos into his world.


     Meanwhile, Angelos is drafted in the army, and by day dutifully goes through all the soldierly duties, learning how to run and walk for long distances, how to use a gun, a knife, to kill. He’s not at all shy in his duties, not a gay weakling, but a strong soldier. But by night, still stationed in Athens, he returns to his sailor, who provides him with love. He determines with his small savings to rent his own place and move out of his family’s home, much to their complaint, since they have evidently survived, in part with his help. As he visits he father and his mother to explain his decision at their jobs, we see how truly dreadful their own lives are. His father works by the docks basically sorting through the masses of junk and detritus that accumulates there, lugging old toilets up to be sent away, burning wood crates, old boards, etc. It is a Sisyphean job with no end. His mother stands in an assembly life that sends them live chickens hung up by their legs which, with scissors in hand, they are asked to cut open their necks.

     Later, he visits he grandmother’s (Maria Alkeou), one of the most interesting character’s in this film filled with figures whose lives might be worth exploring. Even before she arrives, she challenges a group of funeral grievers taking a body off to be buried, who she declares was simply a drunkard, whose wife rightfully left him. When she challenges the personal lives of nearly the women and men in the small party for participating in illicit sex, most of them with her, she admits her long role as a prostitute and is actually stoned by the group, as her beloved grandson Angelos arrives and safely takes her inside. Not only does she speak openly about her own life as a prostitute but demeans her daughter, Angelos’ mother, who she claims was one of the best prostitutes around until she became pregnant, and became a faithful wife to her no-good husband.

      Angelos bows his head, knowing that already he too has entered that world.


      By this time of this encounter, Mihalis has taken him to a party of his transgender whores, who have revealed just how sexual they can be in drag. They gather round pretty boy Angelos and, with cosmetics redo his face, convincing him we would be perfect in drag. He is not happy with the change, but by this time has so bought into Mihalis’ love and his clear attraction to the drag figures, that he agrees to go along, hitting the streets in drag and soon making enough money to buy his boyfriend the bike he always desired.

 


   At first, once he gets into the routine, he seems to even somewhat enjoy it, although according to a Letterboxd commentary in Greek (moniker “Serotoxique”] the real figure on which this story is based, Christos Roussos, declared in his autobiography that he never felt comfortable portraying a woman. And that is still apparent in Maniatis’ acting.

      One night, while out with a man where he sits in a car sucking him off, local neighborhood vigilantes attack the car, pull out the Angelos and his john, rough him up, and take them to the nearest police office explaining that in the neighborhoods they no longer feel safe at nights. If there doesn’t seem to be much logic in their complains—the girls walk the avenue in a seemingly commercial district, and the sexual goings on are quite private until they interfere—the local police office, although reprimanding them for taking law into their own hands, claims to comprehend their worries, and frees them. For Angelos, he spits in his face, notifies his army commanders and, the worst thing he could do, reveals it to Angelos’ family and neighbors.


     The drunken father, having no feelings for his son, is simply worried about what having a fag for a son will mean to his neighbors, and finally becomes so terrified by the situation, that he takes up a kitchen rolling pin and beats it against his head. Angelos, who has been packing his clothes to permanently leave the family, rushes to his side to stop him, along with his mother. The invalid daughter groans with pain and suffering. But even once they have stopped him and tended to his wounds, he jumps up again, grabs a scissors and stabs himself in the stomach. He dies soon after in a local hospital.

      By this time Angelos, lost and almost dumbed by these events, tries to tear up his dresses, but is threatened by Michalis that he will leave if he continues with his crying and blabbering. Angelos promises to stop, and again appears on the streets that night.

      But this time, he is picked up by a rather handsome young man who asks him if they can go to his house, Angelos insisting that it will cost more and that if anyone else is there, he will immediately leave.

      I might say this is one of the saddest scenes of the entire film. Dressed handsomely as a woman, this time in a black wig which does him much more justice that the blonde ones his been wearing, he quickly discovers that the man is married with two children, who he clearly loves. This is his first time in picking up a “woman.” Ane as they begin to have gentle sex, it also becomes clear, he is not at all seeking a drag queen, but a gay sexual experience, being perfectly ready to suck Angelos off. We see them soon after they sexual encounter in bed, Angelos without wig or costume, the men obviously having had wonderful gay sex. It becomes apparent that for some men in this culture, to share a gay experience they have no choice but to pick up one of the “girls.”

      The next night, Angelos is picked up by a man what seems to be a garbage truck, a dicey choice, I would argue. On his new bike, Michalis briefly follows before he turns back, joining this male pimp friends at their local bar.


     The next scene of Angelos is when he awakens, clearly after being slugged and tossed from the truck into a vast garbage unloading spot isolated in the mountains. He slowly climbs the mountains of garbage, some of it falling beneath his feet as new trucks come into drop off their loads, and makes it to the top, where presumably he somehow finds his way back to Athens.

      When he finally returns, Michalis challenges him for having been out all night. Furious by this Angelos lashes out, wrestling with him, arguing where were you who promised to protect men.

     The two men wrestle, Michalis being the stronger finally pinning him down and further raping him through anal sex.


       Angelos awakens the find the sleeping Michalis laying beside him. He gets up, goes to the kitchen, grabs a butcher knife, returns and stabs him to death, also slitting his throat.


        It is the whole damn society who is to blame for this murder. Angelos has simply attempted to love, forced to enter in the dirty sex of those hundreds of men who cannot accept their own sexuality except for nightly pickups of the boys who they pretend are “girls,” rejected by his own family, threatened by nearly everyone including his pimp lover for his very existence. This is not a pretty story that exists in such a hypocritical world in which he must survive.

       The Greeks nominated this film for the 55th Academy Awards for Best Foreign Language Film; it is not surprising that the Academy did not accept such a challenging nominee among their selections. But this film needs to be seen and talked about. I found little review coverage on line.

 

Los Angeles, October 7, 2026

Reprinted from My Queer Cinema blog (October 2026).

 




Index O-Z

Dave O'Brien Straight Boys / 2005 Nick Oceano El primo ( The Cousin ) / 2008  Ken Ochiai Phoenix / 2006 Carlos Ocho Relación Abierta ...