Thursday, October 29, 2026

Iván Zulueta | Arrebato (Rapture) / 1979

i lost my life in the movies

by Douglas Messerli

 

Iván Zulueta (screenwriter and director) Arrebato (Rapture) / 1979

 

My title, of course, echoes Pauline Kael’s early collection of her film essays, I Lost It at the Movies.

I always presumed that by “it” such meant her emotional stability, that the film itself had so moved or wrought her up that she finally had a sort of momentary emotional breakdown. She herself referred to the “it” as “various kinds of innocence” she had lost over the years, relating it almost to a kind of sexual defilement. My husband Howard always felt she meant that the “it” was her metaphorical virginity, and that may indeed be closer to what she was expressing, much to my surprise.


    In the movie I am about to explore, a deep and dark exploration of what making and watching film can do to one, it is far more serious. Here lives are lost, and not at the movies, but in them, not only in their making, as the central figures of this film do. José Sirgado (Eusebio Poncela), a filmmaker of definitely grade B horror films, most recently with a working title of Wolf Men, which the studio wants to change to the much more literal The Curse of the Wolf Men. It may be simply a minor change, but for him, along with his argument with the cuts and reshoots his editor/cutter insists for the final scenes, it is just too much for a man who is still trying to make something out of nothing. José still believes in cinema, despite the fact that his assistant suggests he has been behaving over the past few months in strange and troubling ways, arguing over issues which he is no longer is interested in. As if taking control of José’s own movie, he demands the director simply go home and patch up his relationship with his supposed lover, Ana Turner (Cecilia Roth).

     But things have gone far deeper than anyone can imagine. As we slowly discover in this truly unusual film, by this time presumably José has already broken up with Ana and met up with a young would-be filmmaker Pedro (Wil More) who is the cousin of one of his former lovers Marta (Marta Fernández Muro), who has invited him to her aunt Carmen’s (Carmen Giralt) house where Pedro is currently living, as a possible shooting spot for a future film.


    Pedro is not only beautiful and strange, as Marta describes him, but a sort of mad filmmaker, filming at nearly all moments of the day, who behaves like a child, crying in despair whenever he views what he has filmed for its numerous flaws. He is particularly disturbed about not being able to get the rhythms of his films right, which he studiously counts out. An interval timer, which José, later sends him, changes his entirely filmmaking and life. At the moment, however, he attempts to magically “charm” his new acquaintance, perceiving him as a professional filmmaker who might serve as a mentor to him so that he can make the films to which it is clear he is utterly committed to.


     The charms, however, which include a doll, an old picture book of King Solomon's Mines, and other actions seem to superficially fail. But there is something deeper going on, we perceive, already in this first meeting with Pedro and José, far deeper and more disturbing that simply a “charming.” Despite the sometimes rough and tumble intellectual tangles which commentators Joe Lipsett and his co-anchor Terry get into in their discussions on Queer Horror Movies, Terry actually observes something that most other critics have failed to mention:

 

“Pedro mentions that he’s been creating the same images for centuries. It’s such a bizarre statement that a viewer could take as an exaggeration; that the art of discovering new techniques or perfecting one’s filmmaking skills feels like centuries. But his supernatural knowledge of people and ways to “enrapt” them makes me wonder.

     I’m sure you could look at Arrebato under a multitude of lenses to pick at and analyze what the film is trying to say (if that’s even possible), but one refrain kept coming back to me while watching it. Zulueta imagines filmmaking as an extended form of lovemaking; one that might have no release. After telling José that he’s been making the same images for centuries and apologizing for “all that build-up just to watch that junk,” he compares the creation of film almost as a long, protracted and endless jerk-off session: “one long wank without cumming.”

    Later, when they meet for a second time, after José sends him the all-important timer, Pedro seems even stranger as he, this time, makes sure that José joins him for what both now clearly desire, a sexual encounter with one another.


    Terry, on Queer Horror Encounters observes: “I do wonder if Pedro is more of a metaphor than a real person. Or a personification of the art of filmmaking. Hints are dropped throughout the first half of the film that he might be somewhat supernatural. He talks about how he must “enrapture” Ana, when she shows up with José. He even stages a goth Betty Boop doll, one that is the exact same doll that she had as a kid, including a tear. ‘Isn’t that strange?’”


     It is indeed most strange, as he basically renders her motionless so that he and José can finish their love-making before she again wakes up. Here we have suggestions that perhaps Pedro himself is a kind of vampirish figure from the beginning, not one who sucks blood (although later in the film he seems to do just that with his former female friend Gloria), but so vitally attracts a fellow cinephile like himself that there is no longer any escape. Both are also, it needs to be stated, drug fiends, José deeply addicted to heroin (as was director Zueleta), while Pedro appears to prefer cocaine, although he seems to be far more intoxicated throughout with the drug of cinema.

    When Marta and her aunt sell the house and move to Lourdes, Pedro goes in search of the world, finding the alluring charms of bisexual life, yet finally returning to film with a deeper commitment and vengeance

     His “charms” so attract the already addicted José that for him there is no going back to his persistently now drugged-out girlfriend, particularly when a now gravely spoken half-ghost of Pedro offers him evidence of an even greater escape into the camera lens, explaining how after one last encounter with his girlfriend Gloria and a pickup male, during which he makes love to both, but actually draws blood of the girl, his own self-regulated camera, comes to life, and films him while sleeping, whereupon he discovers frames in which the as he sleeps, now in the complete rapture of being part of the movie itself, in red, as if the being as disappeared. In the final film which he sends José, he and even his cousin Marta who has attempted to return to him in order to bring him back into reality, also disappears into the red, luring José into further action, having given him the key to his own apartment.


   As José attempts to watch the movie, his girlfriend Ana tries to engage him in sex. He pushes her away and finally says he’s leaving, she saying that she has made the same decision, but he replying that it doesn’t matter anymore. She can stay. It is he who is moving on.

    He enters Pedro’s now highrise Madrid apartment to find it totally empty, the final film waiting for him. He simply needs to develop it, which takes at most, three days. During that time he compares the reels Pedro as left behind and sees the increasing red frames that spread across the reels. When he views the new film, Pedro has complete disappeared except for one frame which seems to continue in motion of its own, impossible as that may seem, luring José into Pedro’s own bed. Finally, having now broken in a complete sweat of both having taken no drugs for several days and his own anticipation, he covers his eyes in a tear of the sheets and enters, the camera of itself again coming to life, presumably bringing him into the red “rapture” into which Pedro has previously been consumed.


    Most critics have perceived the metaphor, and some of them have even recognized how possible it actually is to have occurred in their own lives. In Carlos Aguilar’s 2021 review on the Roger Ebert site, for example, he ends his review:

 

“Arrebato invokes cinema as an otherworldly entity that possesses, just as addictive and destructive as mind-altering substances injected into the bloodstream. The camera itself is an apparition that devours the lifeforce from those enraptured in its powers. It’s a movie about losing oneself to the dangerously numbing power of experiencing life on a different level of consciousness, whether chemically induced or through a lens. The more removed the men are from devastating sobriety, the closer they are to being forever trapped inside the reel. To an extent, aren’t all cinephiles susceptible to such fate?”

  

     My “first” addiction is alcohol, not drugs. And throughout my life I have also been equally addicted to, first drama, then fiction and poetry, before film, time and life-consuming activities that completely transformed my own way of perceiving and living, forcing me to disappear at times within their productions, pages, and screen images. My husband Howard has certainly complained vehemently about just such vast distances that occurred between us because of those addictions. Although, for many years, he was equally involved in the world of art, much larger than the mere adoration of what an artist puts on a canvas or constructs or performs. The world of art is a completely surrounding world of needy others equally involved in the adoration of their shrines. The worlds I chose were singular, “raptures” one had to experience mostly alone and apart, in “the red” zone so to speak.

     As strange as Zueleta’s film must have seemed in 1979, and still does to many today, for me it is a history less than a horror or ghost tale. The oddities of it make total sense, such as the dubbing of Ana’s voice early on in the film by noted Spanish direct Pedro Almodóvar which makes her, at least for a few moments, sound almost like a transgender figure as opposed to the woman she no longer can be. Almodóvar, accordingly, cites this movie as one of the best of Spanish cinema—as many others have—and has highly influenced him, as many observers have also argued, although I see only superficial similarities, except the obvious sexual fluidity of this film’s characters.

    Is Zueleta’s a great film? Yes…and no. In its attempts to link the crazed student Pedro and his self-determined mentor José, the trickery of charms and mesmerist behavior doesn’t always work, unless you truly do read this as a kind a latent vampirism that he possesses. What finally draws José to Pedro is desire, first for the body but just as much for the talent of the young man who has not yet abandoned his cinematic talents and is truly willing to fall into tears, cry, and give up his life for them, something José devoutly wishes he had been able to do, before he gave into the studio-driven film world. The musical passage from Wagner’s final strains from Götterdämmerung which end this film call up both a sexual and spiritual release to what has truly made his life meaningful. There is nothing more to be said. He too, is ready to be “red.”

 

Los Angeles, October 29, 2026

Reprinted from My Queer Cinema blog (October 2026).

Tabea Blumenschein and Ulrike Ottinger | Madame X - Eine absolute Herrscherin (Madame X: An Absolute Ruler) / 1978

the women’s collective of death

by Douglas Messerli

 

Ulrike Ottinger (screenplay), Tabea Blumenschein and Ulrike Ottinger (directors) Madame X - Eine absolute Herrscherin (Madame X: An Absolute Ruler) / 1978

 

Obviously, Virginia Woolf’s fictional biography Orlando was central to Ulrike Ottinger’s early films. The figure first appears in her 1972-73 work Laocoon & Son and is the central focus of her 1978 prequel Madame X: An Absolute Ruler to her “Berlin Trilogy,” the centerpiece of which is Freak Orlando (1981). Using yet another trope of feminine empowerment, this Madame X is a brutal sea pirate, who like James M. Barrie’s Captain Hook has lost one of her hands in an attempt to save her female lover Orlando from a poisonous species of sea anemone which she thought was a flower, and dived in to retrieve.


      Calling out to women around the world to join her, Madame X accrues an odd assortment of females representing various stereotypes of unhappy women, both lesbians and formerly heterosexually married individuals, among them a housewife whose husband has left her for another woman, Betty Brillo (Lutze, who will later be central to Ticket with No Return); a worn-out artist seeking new subjects and landscapes, Joseph de Collage who roller skates away from her entrapment (noted dancer, choreographer, and filmmaker Yvonne Rainer); a German woman living outdoors with her trusty rifle at hand, Flora Tannenbaum (Claudia Skoda); a beautiful “Tahitian” girl, punished by her husband for some action or inaction by being manacled and sent off in a small paddle raft, Noa-Noa (Roswitha Janz); along with a medical psychologist and a female pilot—all lured by her calls for “gold, love, and adventure.”


     While these may on one level represent various feminist figures, they are also presented by Ottinger as satirical, and many of the women taken aboard by the Orientalist figurehead—Madame X also serves as the maidenhead of her dinghy—do not survive the voyage, some of them destroyed by their leader herself. And although at moments the women do join together in a kind of feminist collective, just as often they plot, bicker, and gossip against one another. Neither are all of them true to the lesbian cause, Betty Brillo, in particular, later being punished for her interest in a sailor illegally brought aboard.

      When early in their voyage they also bring on board a castrato/fool, Belmondo (Mackay Taylor) who has been set afloat by a crew aboard a wealthy yacht simply for being so “different,” one might almost argue that Madame X’s dinghy acquires a slightly “rainbow” quality. But even the obvious effeminate “fairy” is so kooky and bizarre in his behavior that the medical psychologist immediately interviews him in a hilarious series of quick-fired questions which accuse him more than attempting to explore his peculiarities.

      One of the first things the crew must accomplish is to simply attract the attention of their cruel and absolute ruler, who seems oblivious of their presence, so much so that fear they might never even be served something to eat. Through a lottery it is decided that Noa-Noa will be the one to approach her.


    The encounter at first results in a fury of hostility (with the help of the canned sound of snarling tiger), but gradually as the Tahitian offers her onions and, the most absurd of offerings, large flowers of broccoli, as well as her own enticing body, Madame is calmed as Noa-Noa and her make symbolic gestures of love, the girl becoming her favorite thereafter.

     Almost immediately after this quite charming enticement, Madame X orders her ferocious-looking servant Hoi Sin (obviously jealous of her master’s attentions to Noa-Noa) to feed her crew with a large Chinese cooked fish, which the hungry female collective consume with the speed of a gathering of locusts.

      When the speechless Belmondo mimes the story of his being cast away, he describes the yacht filled with the mindless well-to-to individuals that have had no place for him, Madame X determines the course of the first (and only) adventure depicted in this film, which is clearly meant to be an ongoing series like the old silent serials such as the Fantômas crimes series of the 1920s or the Pirate Gold series of the same decade.


      Catching up with yacht, the dinghy provides the rich and bored people on cruise such an exotic sight filled with magnificently dressed (and in Noa-Noa’s case undressed) beings that they invite them aboard, muttering endless banalities and oohing-and-awing over the strangeness of these figures as they poke and prod them like so many pieces of art, snapping photos as if on one of Ottinger’s later ethnographic visits to an alien world. A wheel-chair-bound female singer serves as the center of the fatuous folk looked after by beautiful young sailor and others who might serve their sexual needs.


      Madame X and her crew, sans Belmondo, allow themselves to be the subjects of outsider fascination until the sun sets when one-by-one they kill off the entire batch of the idol and rich, and plunder their safes below deck of jewels and money. The young sailor, however, dives overboard and swims to the dingy crying out for help, where the confused Belmondo saves him and the two, enwrapped in a small cocoon of a glass-surrounded room begin to make love so intensely that they do not, at first, even recognize the return of the pirates, who stare in intently at their love-making, Betty Brillo, in particular, becoming so jealous that even when the others report the incident to their cruel leader and she has put the sailor upon a net hanging over the waters, Betty is still determined to join him, as is Belmondo who fight for possession of the beauty.

     Belmondo finally gives up, and as Betty crawls into the net in an attempt to have sex with the sailor, they are dropped together into the ocean, only Belmondo escaping death. His punishment by Madame X soon after is surprisingly allayed in a gesture of mercy that she does not show the others who soon after begin to resist her cruel behavior. One by one, some of her crew members are killed off for their various mutinies and offences. The pilot is poisoned with cake (see the second photo in this essay).


     After taking a long bath, the hairy-chested Madame X orders Belmondo and another to kill someone watching nearby.

     Another is killed as she attempts to stab Madame X as she performs her role as the maidenhead (see the first image of the essay).  Finally, as they reach port, she has the medical psychologist who has kept a private log of her wrongdoings, shot through by an arrow.

     What Madame X has not warned these women is that their servitude in the new cause may also result in their deaths.


     Back in port, Madame X and her dinghy magically attract a whole new series of women, a hot-dog stand owner, a park sweeper dressed in what looks like a prison uniform, and others who are the same actors, in many cases, as the previous ones she has destroyed in their former personas, as if they have metamorphosed into new women desiring “gold, love, and adventure.” Indeed, this time the voyage is treated almost as a park ride, as the women sail out of port as if they soon will be returning from a tour adventure not so very different from the one of those on the doomed yacht.

     As in nearly all of Ottinger’s works, it is the visual splendor of her images and cinematic wit that most matters. Nothing is ever truly predictable in the world in which this director takes her adventurous viewers, and every time one takes the cinematic voyage with her, new discoveries are there to be uncovered.

 

Los Angeles, December 5, 2022

Reprinted from World Cinema Review (December 2022).

Titles Index A-N

https://myqueercinema.blogspot.com/2023/12/former-index-to-world-cinema-review.html Films discussed (listed alphabetically by director) [F...