by Douglas Messerli
David Brown (screenwriter and director) Rural Heat / 1997
The school is preparing for its annual
theatrical productions of various kinds, including a presentation of a
selection from Oscar Wilde’s The Importance of Being Ernest. Various of
the performers, directors, and school mistresses are gathered backstage as we
hear a constant voice- over of announcements for the performances.
Matthew is more than a little startled by the fact his friend Gregory
had told his parents all about their gay relationship. Gregory suggests they
would have found out in any event and that it’s better this way. He also
suggests that Matthew is going to have to tell “her,” since Gregory’s mother is
also going to tell “her” as well. Whether “her” refers to his apparent
“girlfriend” Bernadette—who pulls Matthew demanding he help her with her
lines—or his mother—who is one of the multiple directors of this affair—is
uncertain. In any event, Gregory soon spots Matthew and Bernadette (Mia
Gallagher) kissing. It doesn’t help for Matthew to explain that it was her
doing, not his. Even his admitting to Gregory that he loves him doesn’t seem to
help.
Chaos is let loose upon the stage in the form of magic tricks,
sword-swallowing, and backstage high jinks. But soon the Wilde scene begins,
with Jack having to admit that he believes Algernon to be untrustworthy. But
suddenly he begins to change the lines, admitting that “We share the
unspeakable vice of the Greek.” The backstage prompter is most confused, the schoolmistress
becoming quite distraught with the line change, although anyone who has ever
seen the play realizes that if Wilde could, he might have written just such a
line into that work.
In
1996, the year previous to this short film, Hettie Macdonald’s Beautiful
Thing had demonstrated two boys coming out without the full public
announcement of this work, and by the next year, British director Simon Shore’s
Get Real and American director David Moreton’s Edge of Seventeen would
establish the basic format of the genre as a feature film that I’ve described
as the “Coming Out” movie, version B. But this short Irish work has to be
described as the first film to represent that genre’s essentials: the admission
to each other of their gay love, a temporary or permanent break in their
relationship due to the unreadiness of one of the lovers, and the final public
announcement of gay sexuality, accepted or rejected by parents and society in
general.
The
quality of the DVD I saw was far from excellent and, as so very may amateur
productions, the sound along with the heavy Irish accents create problems for
Brown’s film school project, particularly for the American ear. Let us hope
that this important 13-minute work will soon be restored and brought into a
better format with subtitles.
Los Angeles, July 10, 2023
Reprinted from World Cinema Review (July
2023).
















