the perfect child
by
Douglas Messerli
Lucía
Puenzo (screenwriter, based on a story by Sergio Bizzio, and director) XXY /
2007
Suli
(Valeria Bertuccelli) and her husband Néstor Kracken (Ricardo Darin), a marine
biologist, have been almost model Argentinian parents. With the birth of the
child Alex (Inés Efron) they were faced by an intersex child, with both female
and male genitalia. Although doctors immediately suggested surgical
intervention, they felt that they would be making their own child’s decision
for it, and refused an operation that would have probably removed the male genitals.
Accordingly, Alex has grown up in “her” own way (and although Alex is still very
much in flux in terms of gender, I will continue to describe her in this essay
as her, since at the moment of the film it is primarily how the now 15-year old
presents herself to the public; a role, incidentally played by a 20-some year
old woman).

Yet
growing up in Buenos Aires as what we used to describe as a hermaphrodite has
not been easy, and to protect Alex from bullying the family has moved several
times, and is now living in Uruguay on a remote island where most of the men
are simple fishermen and Kraken can continue his career, saving the marine life
in danger that the fishermen report to him. Yet even here there are new
problems brewing as Alex has just broken the nose of her former best friend, Vando
(Luciano Nóbile) to whom she has revealed her condition and accordingly
attempted to witness her genitalia. Moreover, she has recently begun to refuse
the several medications she has been taking to suppress the outward
manifestations of her male appearance; in short, she is now questioning what
gender she might wish to choose or even if she wants necessarily to choose a
particular gender.
Unbeknownst to her husband, Suli has
invited an outstanding surgeon Ramiro (Germán Palacios) and his wife Erika (Carolina
Pelleritti), who happens to be an old friend of hers, along with their son Álvaro
(Martin
Piroyanski) to their home with the possibility of convincing her husband and daughter
to undergo the removal of her male genitalia. But even as they arrive she has
still not told her husband about her intentions.
Alex, however, picks up quickly why
the “kindly” doctor and his wife are visiting. She goes immediately after the
son Álvaro who is intrigued, if nothing else by her wild nature, particularly when
she suggests that he has been wanking off and she answers that she too does it
daily.
She
later asks if he would like to have sex, but he quickly refuses, arguing she is
too young (he is 16, she 15). But shortly after, following her through the
woods one day, and later into a barn, the two do begun a sort of sexual
wrestling, she eventually topping him and fucking him, with her father briefly
watching them through the door, whereupon they stop, she running off.
Later, she apologizes to Álvaro, but he admits
that he enjoyed it, making it clear that the boy, probably gay, is having his
own difficulties with sexual maturity.
Néstor,
having witnessed their encounter, recognizes that Alex is now old enough to
make her own decisions about sexual identity, and after rereading a newspaper
article he has saved, drives a rather long distance to meet with a transgender
man about whom he has read. The man, now married to a woman and about to adopt
a child, explains that it is good they did not make the decision for her. He
himself had undergone several operations before finally realizing that he truly
wanted to be male; but for him, who had been forced to take drugs and behave as
a woman, it had been a difficult route to his final destination. After talking
with him, Néstor
is more than ever convinced that the decision must be Alex’s alone.

But meanwhile, Suli, having driven with
her friends to an isolated spot, explains to them that Alex has abandoned her
medications, Ramiro quickly explaining that she will soon begin to demonstrate
masculine characteristics including hair; he argues that he should immediately
use his skill to operate as he has many a time so as to
transform
Alex into a female without male genitalia, making her transition to a female
far easier and assured.
Néstor
has now become quite aware of why they are visiting and confronts his wife, who reports
they are only their to observe and advice. But he quickly becomes gruff with
the doctor, accusing him of trying to force the decision upon his wife and
Alex.
Soon after, in her wandering, along the
beach, Alex is accosted by other friends of Vando demanding she pull down her
pants to reveal her genitalia, and when she refuses force her quite brutally to
do so. In a sense, they are just curious, but in their behavior and attitude
they also have rendered her a freak and if not actually, certainly symbolically
raped her.
Recognizing that reporting to the assault to the police would only alert
the entire village to his daughter’s situation, he along with Ramiro drive to
the beach, violently confronting the boys and Vando’s still angry father, Néstor
finally lashing out at Ramiro by slugging him in the nose, declaring that he
too is part of the problem.
When Néstor, with care and gentleness,
asks his “daughter” whether she desires to be male or female, she simply shrugs
her shoulders, answering “What if there is nothing to choose?”
It is now clear that the doctor and his
wife are no longer welcome in the Kracken household, as his wife begins packing
for their return to Buenos Aires. Ramiro pleads for one last chance to talk to Néstor; but even he finally perceives that neither the father or mother are any longer
interested in making the choice for their child.
Meanwhile, observing his pouting son, who
admits his interest in Alex. Ramiro expresses his relief, believing that Álvaro
has fallen for her as a female, expressing he had feared he was a fag. The
viewer finally perceives the good doctor for whom he really is, a narrow minded
homophobe ready to make the sexual decisions for all young people who have not
yet understood what those decisions might mean to their lives.
Finally, at the ferry entry, Álvaro and Alex
encounter one another again, she expressing that fact that she never imagined
she might have fallen for someone like him, he showing her that he has now
begun to wear the turtle tag she had previously given him as a gift. “Will we
ever meet again,” he wonders, as she speaks the reality that it is highly
unlikely. But when he attempts to kiss her, she pushes him away, suggesting he
only loves her so that he can get it, forcing him to see her male genitalia.
Ramiro comes to pull him away, as she stands by the sea wall in tears alone before again
joining her family.
Alex takes hold of her father’s hand as
they walk way.
Although Roger Ebert in this review of the
film seemed confused by some events and refused to even mention the nature of
the sexual encounter between Álvaro and Alex, the last paragraph of his review
nicely sums up the fairly objective tone of this film, which despite its
dramatic events, never becomes melodramatic or distracts us from its true focus
of a young intersex person terrified by what may lie ahead, but doing her best
to keep it all from happening.
“We
understand that Alex is in despair, and we see it reflected in a sketchbook she
has drawn. She is weary of being poked and prodded by the unhealthy curiosity
of society, weary of being considered a freak. Alex wants to be accepted as
herself but is not sure who that is. In wanting her to find happiness, her
parents provide a refuge, even though they hardly even discuss her
intersexuality with her in so many words. And finally that’s why this film can
avoid a “solution” and yet end with a bittersweet glow.”
This is certainly not a film everyone will
easily take to, but I thought it brave and thoroughly absorbing, and loved the
tenderness, particularly of the father, toward his child who he admits when
first saw upon birth seemed “perfect.”
Los
Angeles, October 26, 2026
Reprinted
from My Queer Cinema blog (October 2026).