Wednesday, February 25, 2026

Jean Epstein | La Chute de la maison Usher (The Fall of the House of Usher) / 1928

painting his wife into her grave

by Douglas Messerli

 

Jean Epstein (screenwriter and director, based on the story by Edgar Allen Poe) La Chute de la maison Usher (The Fall of the House of Usher) / 1928

 

Born in 1897 in Warsaw, then the Kingdom of Poland, part of the Russian Empire, to a French-Jewish father and a Polish mother, Jean Epstein moved with his mother to Switzerland after the death of his father in 1908 where he began studies in medicine at the University of Lyon in France. In Lyon he worked as secretary and translator for Auguste Lumière, who with his brother Louis, were the often-described as the “inventors” of cinema.

    In 1922 he started directing his own films, the first with Louis Pasteur, but soon working in a manner associated with “French Impressionism” or what is described as the “first cinematic avant-garde” which also included figures such as Louis Delluc, Germaine Dulac, Marcel L’Herbier, and Abel Gance, the latter of whose wife appears as Madeline in La Chute de la maison Usher.

     Before Usher Epstein made 15 films, most of which had long been forgotten but many of which have since become available on DVD.

      Epstein was also a noted film theorist which can already be evidenced in his early 1923 movie Cœur fidèle in which he sought to film a simple tale of love and violence in a manner “to win the confidence of those, still so numerous, who believe that only the lowest of melodrama can interest the public.” Epstein hoped to create “a melodrama so stripped of all the conventions ordinarily attached to the genre, so sober, so simple, that it might approach the nobility and excellence of tragedy.”


     Epstein’s major theoretical concepts were centered on his rather complex notion of photogénie which, on one level, spoke of film as a medium that transcends its photochemical/mechanical essence, which, in the right hands becomes art. Rather than being simply a cultural representation of events and characters, he sought through expression—the close-up (his particular emphasis), movement, temporality, rhythm, and other augmentation of senses such as musical accompaniment and sound (even before he worked in that medium), etc—to transform a narrative representation of events into art.

       Recognizing that some filmmakers would not and could not abandon naturalistic representation and purely photographical aspects of cinema, he also perceived that some audiences would not be able to recognize aspects of photogénie, separating his viewers into those who could see and comprehend the cinematic augmentations to the basic narrative and those who could not.

       This is truly a quite brilliant distinction, which does not necessarily demean those who cannot see what he is attempting to reveal to them, but establishes a differentiation of viewers which ultimately explains why filmmakers would later be able to create devices of coding that could mean somethings to certain audience members that left others in the dark. I am not sure that  Epstein even realized the ramifications of his distinctions, but he proved to be absolutely correct in his assessment about those for whom he was making his films, a realization which would become of special importance for LGBTQ viewers in the near future when, in the US in particular, the Hays censors begin to look for obvious references to sexuality, and in particular, homosexuality.

        For Epstein, moreover, photogénie was not just something that existed in the film. It included an approach or a way of thinking about film. Indeed, it does not literally exist in the film except metaphorically as a way designed to encourage us to take a more active part in the cinematic experience resulting in a deeper gaze into the screen.

        As I recently explained it to a friend: I prefer films that seem to be slightly askew, which are not easily assimilable. Sometimes what later become my favorite films are ones about which I first feel frustrated, at times even angry about for not doing what most other films do or even quite accomplishing what they first set out to achieve. They move off into inexplicable directions, change lanes in the midst of where one thinks the narrative might be driving them. Yet still they’re ravishingly beautiful, revelatory, the camera sometimes taking me into new corners of a frame where I have never before been. Generally, to come to “understand” such films, I have to watch again.  And again. Have to ask myself and the film questions. And then see it all over once more.

       In fact, not all films are able to incorporate photogénie. particularly if they were highly driven by plot. Cinema, he argued, was not screened theater, and the film, if possible, should strip away narrative and story to get to the heart of the medium. It was not that he was determined to dismiss human drama and emotion, but rather seek out from a minimal narrative the same emotions. And in this sense he was attempting to create a film that was neither like mainstream directors such as Louis Feuillade or the advocates of pure cinema such as Marcel Duchamp, Man Ray, or Fernand Léger.

     As Robert Farmer in his 2010 essay on Epstein in Senses of Cinema—many of whose ideas are those I have expressed in my comments above—summarizes, quoting Epstein: “There are no stories, there never have been stories. There are only situations, having neither head nor tail; without beginning, middle or end,” which are not close to not even having stories since nothing very much happens.

     But, of course, a great deal does happen in a work such as Epstein’s La Chute de la maison Usher—just not to whom you have expected and how you might have imagined things might happen. Working with Luis Buñuel as his assistant editor, Epstein combined surrealist concepts with expressionistic elements to create one of his most important works, and the one for which he is still most remembered.



     First of all, Epstein tosses out certain aspects of Poe’s story and incorporates a few elements from his “The Oval Portrait.” In his film Roderick Usher (Jean Debucourt) is married to Madeline (Marguerite Gance) and she is no longer his twin sister, thus eradicating any need to for him to pursue the issues of incest. If this tactic appears to solidify Usher’s heterosexuality, Epstein also confuses the issue by introducing yet another element that seems to come from Oscar Wilde’s The Portrait of Dorian Gray—itself a somewhat sexually ambiguous story since the obviously gay hero seems primarily to be exploring liaisons with women throughout the fiction, while obviously, simultaneously destroying their reputations and ending their lives. In this case Roderick spends much of the film painting a portrait of his wife, an activity evidently demanded of each Usher heir before the death of their wives, another odd Usher tribal tradition. In this case, however, it seems to be his very act of painting that is the cause of Madeline’s catalepsy; the more he paints her, the sicker she becomes. It is as if he is drawing the essence out of her in order to turn her into a work of art—which, if you recall, is what Dorian’s artist friend Basil Hallwood accomplished by painting the young hero, drawing his soul out of his body and entombing it within the painting.

       Since Epstein has no need of a storyteller, Roderick’s visitor (Charles Lamy) is pushed off into the sidelines as a mere token of the role which the director’s camera will replace and we, the audience, are the ones whom it is attempting to engage. The friend, once he has been summoned, seems suddenly to be an intrusion in Roderick’s life, and despite serving him a dinner Usher refuses to join him in dining and soon sends him off on a walk around the grounds for his health. During the period after Madeline’s burial Roderick hardly bothers to see or talk to his friend, and when the storm rises, Usher sends him into his own room to read so that he will not need to witness the scene of Madeline’s resurrection since it may disturb him too much.


       Roderick is not only obsessed by his painting—and not, we realize with the painting’s subject—but is almost irritated by the presence of the invited guest. But then, why shouldn’t he want to be alone since he is quite literally through that activity killing off his wife. No longer suffering the immediate hypersensitivity of Poe’s Roderick, this Usher seems quite aware of the effects of his actions, enjoying himself in the process.

       Yet something is terribly amiss as the curtains wave in and out; other people such as the doctor he abhors, gather round him in an attempt to deter him or explain his actions, and the winds wind around the vast spaces of the almost empty mansion as if to remind us that the entire house, like its master, is possessed. As film critic Richard Scheib describes it: “The interior of the House of Usher is all vast, empty sets—like a soundstage with giant high walls and random pieces of furniture placed in the middle of the bare space around which the action occurs.”

      When Madeline does appear at brief intervals it is nearly always when the guest is not present, and she is so very frail and white that at certain moments she fades in and out of frame as if she is a disappearing woman, which of course is presumably what Roderick desires. Scheib notes the fact that “Madeleine is killed when Roderick obsessively transfers too much of her lifeforce into the picture.”

     If in Poe’s telling we had first to ask what Madeline represents in relationship Roderick—his other hidden self—in this case he are forced to inquire why does he wish to get rid of his “other,” particularly since she represents his other half, not precisely his “double.” The question seems to boil down to whether he’s attempting to rid himself of his heterosexuality or a homosexuality of which he’s ashamed. Has he invited his friend in order to be able to fully return the many hugs and touches the other awards to Roderick?

     In any event, he soon finishes the portrait and declares his wife dead. In this case, however, the worry is not some vague fear that her body might be stolen by graverobbers, but that Madeline is not yet truly dead, that his artifice is not as totally effective as he has imagined it is. And the friend seems to be equally aware of that possibility. As the doctor insistently proceeds to nail up the coffin, Roderick forbids it. And as in the fiction, Roderick determines to bury her in the family crypt, which, in this instance, does not truly appear to be within the house but across the lake on an island a ways from the mansion itself.

    In one of the film’s most surreal scenes Madeline’s funeral cortege is witnessed as the four pallbearers carry her down a row of wind-ridden trees, the image superimposed with candles, while remnants of her burial gown, which looks more like a wedding dress, trail in the wind behind.


 


     Even more terrifying are the images once they have laid her coffin in the crypt of Roderick’s hammer-happy doctor beginning the process of nailing the cover to the bottom of the coffin, while his friend holds him back, hugging and caressing him deeply to calm him from attempting to stop the necessary process. Here we actually do see an expression of deep physical love played out on the screen that goes on for several restless seconds. And suddenly it does appear that Roderick might be able to engage in a true relationship with his “friend.”

      But guilt now blocks their apparent love for one another, as Usher finally begins to show signs of the hypersensitivity he felt from the beginning in Poe’s version, the title card reading “The slightest sound exacerbated him.”


     As the storm rises, he joins his friend momentarily in his bedroom, and again they seem to hold one another by the window, perhaps more in fear that in love, but nonetheless joining in bodily communication. Yet Usher soon retreats, knowing what is about to happen, demanding, as I said above, that his friend read so as to not to have to encounter the specter he is about to.

      After a nearly interminable period with the pages of books flapping through air, objects skittering down the hallways, and the return again and again of images of the ticking clockwork alternating with close-ups of an almost smiling Roderick, opening accepting the inevitable, Madeline finally does appear, Usher shouting out that he knew what he and his friend had done, “We have buried her alive!”


     At this point in a clear and purposely crude mockup of the Usher mansion, fire breaks out, walls begin to collapse. We see the friend retreating, but we also witness images of Roderick lifting up Madeline as if attempting to escape the cataclysm. We vaguely see them on what appears to be outside the estate, but we can’t be certain. Yet, it seems that possibly they have escaped. The fact doesn’t truly matter, however, since he has not been able to escape his doom. He has not been able to further embrace his friend and is tied to the living-dead woman in his arms forever.

     Accordingly, it appears that Epstein has shifted Poe’s tale of a being locked within the closet of his own confused sexuality into a story about a man attempting unsuccessfully to escape just such an entombment. The ending may appear to be the same, but at least Epstein’s Roderick Usher tried desperately to become a man freed by his own artistry, to re-engage with the world outside of his closed off existence, refusing to passively embrace the terrible oppression of marriage and family duties.

 

Los Angeles, September 4, 2021

Reprinted from World Cinema Review (September 2021).

Douglas Messerli | Sleeping Around: The Secret Gay History of Roderick Usher [essay]

sleeping around: the secret gay history of roderick usher

by Douglas Messerli

 

If you haven’t recently reread your Edgar Allen Poe, let me remind you of the plot of tale The Fall of the House of Usher. It begins with the unnamed narrator arriving at the mansion house of his old friend Roderick Usher. Roderick has written a letter to his “one and only friend,” asking him to visit him at his home as soon as possible. He has been suffering from an undescribed illness and his twin sister Madeline seems to be encountering cataleptic seizures, falling into a deathlike trance from which it is increasingly difficult to awaken her.

      Brother and sister are the last heirs of the Usher estate, whose home, as the narrator has noted, is in sad repair, a thin crack descending from the roof down across the center of the house and into the nearby tarn itself.

      Roderick greets him warmly and serves him supper, although there is no sign of Madeline. And after supper he plays improvised songs on his guitar. The friend is impressed by Roderick’s paintings and library, and attempts to cheer his friend by reading to him aloud.

      One of the songs which Roderick performs is Poe’s “The Haunted Palace,” a song which evokes its singer to express that he believes the very house in which he lives to be alive, connected to living by its very masonry and the surrounding vegetation. His fate, he asserts, lies with the survival of the family mansion.

      Although the friend never actually encounters Madeline, one morning Roderick announces that she has died. He fears her body, if buried, might be exhumed for medical purposes, a common practice, as he note in the film Frankenstein, of the day. Accordingly, he insists his twin be entombed for two weeks in the family tomb, located in the house itself, before being permanently buried. The narrator helps Roderick put her in the tomb, noting that she still has rosy cheeks, but explains it as a common occurrence after death.

       Over the next weeks, both Roderick and his friend grow quite sensitive to sound and suffer a great deal of mental agitation.

        As a large storm rises, Roderick enters the narrator’s bedroom in a highly disturbed state of mind, throwing open the widows to point out that the lake nearby is almost glowing in the dark, just as Roderick had painted it in his artworks. Yet there is no lightning or other source of its incredible luminosity.

        His friend attempts to calm down Roderick by reading aloud a medieval romance, The Mad Trist, involving Ethelred, a knight who attempting to escape a storm breaks into a hermit’s dwelling, only to find there a palace of gold which is guarded by a dragon. Upon the wall hangs a shield upon which is inscribed:

 

                    Who entereth herein, a conqueror hath bin;

                    Who slayeth the dragon, the shield he shall win....

 

The knight swings his mace at the dragon, killing it, the beast dying with a shrill shriek. When he attempts to take down the shield it falls to the floor with an incredible rumbling sound.

       At the very same moment, he and Roderick hear loud cracking and ripping sounds from somewhere in the house, and as the dragon’s cries are read, a real shriek is heard within the house.

       Horrified by the sounds, Roderick admits that he has been hearing the sounds for days, and he realizes that they are coming from the tomb of his sister, knowing that she has been buried alive.

       At that very moment, the bedroom door blows open revealing a bloodied Madeline, having escaped her tomb. In a rage she attacks her brother, the two of them dying in the terror of the event.

     As the narrator runs from the house, he perceives a flash of moonlight behind him, and turning back toward the house he realizes that the crack in the house as widened, soon after the mansion splitting in two and sinking into the surrounding lake.

      

*

 

As I have noted in other essays throughout these volumes on LGBTQ film, Poe appears to be a central source for several of the cinematic narratives that embrace the 19th century US author’s concerns with the double and the twin, standard metaphors for the dual life lived by numerous closeted gay figures and other LGBTQ individuals who feel that they are of another sexuality from the body in which they are trapped. Poe’s presentation of outsider figures who for their peculiar obsessions and deviations do not fit into normative society also appeal to LGBTQ filmmakers, and I have cited works such as “William Wilson” and “The Tell-Tale Heart” as being sources for some movies.

      Yet “The Fall of the House of Usher,” a seemingly heterosexual family tale seems to be one of the most influential of all Poe’s works on LGBTQ cinema. The question we must ask before proceeding to discuss the films concerning this tale—by the homosexual French filmmaker Jean Epstein, whose great surrealist-influence La Chute de la maison Usher was released in 1928; the gay-friendly directors James Sibley Watson and Melville Webber who shot their own experimental version to the story, The Fall of the House of Usher the same year; and gay moviemaker Curtis Harrington who remade his high school cinema project of 1942 into Usher in 2000—why Poe’s tale so attracted them and what might it have to do with the LGBTQ experience.

      Obviously, the original’s male/female twin characters, whose lives are quite clearly intertwined suggests yet another instance of “doubling,” in this case representing not only a hidden “other” gay self behind the heterosexual exterior—Madeline does not even bother to show up for Roderick’s narrator-friend—but the sexual “other” that many gay men, lesbians, and nearly all transsexual and transgender individuals feel as representative of their cultural and personal dilemmas. In Poe’s tale Roderick experiences himself to be not only one with the house, but the mansion’s other version of himself, a feeling many twins experience.

 


      If Roderick appears to be a heterosexual with regard to his love of and obsession with Madeline, it is really or at least equally a love and obsession with his own self, his own multiple feelings of sexuality. Poe makes it quite apparent that, just as Roderick is one with the house of Usher, he is similarly “one” with the Ushers, Madeline as well. What she suffers so does he in hypersensitive-related matters, and when he dies so does she. They are inseparable. In short, we have to presume that in some mysterious manner Roderick and Madeline are one and the same, an easy slip into transvestite and transgender issues. 

     His identification with the place in which he lives, moreover, ties in with the general sense of many LGBTQ individuals before sexual liberation who felt their real essence was only able to be expressed “inside,” within the walls of their own home, while the outside world required them to be someone else in order fit within the normative societal patterns.

      And then, of course, there is Roderick’s mysterious male friend who has been summoned as witness to this hidden universe. Who is he and what is his relationships with Roderick, we must ask?

      The story makes clear that he is not a close friend and that, in fact, Roderick has never been able to develop close friendships. Yet obviously he is someone trusted enough that he will not recoil at the very oddity of Roderick’s lifestyle and obsessions. As witness, he serves the extremely important role, moreover, of being able to explain the seemingly inexplicable to the rest of the world. His intelligence, empathy, and equanimity, accordingly, are extremely important. Without any one of these elements, he will be unable to return the hermit Roderick to his place in the society, the world outside of his virtual entombment. The fact that the narrator takes pleasure in both his music and his art is almost a test of his abilities, and a crucial matter in Poe’s narrative. If Roderick is indeed queer, it is important that he and his sister are not represented as freaks or grotesques abhorrent to normative society. Their histories may be described as frightening, terrifying, and ultimately, even edifying, but must not be perceived as dreadful, horrifying, or an abysmal example of human life.

      If the narrator may not have been the young Roderick’s lover, he was at least a trusted early companion, someone beloved and admired and certainly respected. And for his part, the narrator does become an active figure in the last days of the Ushers’ lives, serving as someone who soothes Roderick’s nerves, hears out his woes, and helps him to bury Madeline, or the feminine aspect of himself—even while that has horrible consequences. And in that sense, the stranger is also a co-conspirator of the story’s hero. It is he who allows the central figure to survive through the last days of his life, who consoles him for his actions, and eventually, through telling his story, turns him into a romantic hero. The friend is Roderick’s only link to the outer, “other” world.

      In the end, accordingly, what Roderick is asking his friend to do is to narrate a life generally unknown to the outside world: the world of an incestuous couple perhaps—but more importantly the experiences of someone normative society has difficulty in comprehending, someone who, like any LGBTQ individual, is queer and needs to have his or her life explained to others when he or she failed to successfully communicate it. Whether his friend is gay or straight, he is being asked to do something similar to what any LGBTQ historian, cultural critic, or even a cinema commentator like myself, tries to do.

      Finally, particularly in Epstein’s film, there is, in fact, a deep homoerotic tension between Roderick and his invited friend, of not a closeted homosexual relationship that is sublimated and, at other points, even coded with both Epstein’s and Watson and Webber’s films.

 

Los Angeles, September 6, 2021

Reprinted from World Cinema Review (September 2021).

Tuesday, February 24, 2026

Publico Groupe | Müller Mile High Club / 2002 [commercial advertisement]

Müller Love

By Douglas Messerli

 

Publico Groupe (director) Müller Mile High Club / 2002 [31 seconds] [commercial advertisement]

 

Playing on the bisexual airline porn romp of 2001, Chi Chi LaRue’s Mile Bi Club, the British yoghurt makers, Müller, present a man and woman, sitting beside one another on a plane (it’s never made clear whether they are strangers, friends, or a married couple) who decide to try out sex in the plane bathroom.


    The male goes first, stripping off his clothes almost the moment he enters the small chamber. The woman rises to follow him, but at very moment the stewardess passes by with a tray of Müller yoghurt cups, offering her a strawberry container.


      The woman finds the idea very appealing and sits back down in her sea as she begins to savor the delicious treat, seemingly having completely forgotten about her sexual rendezvous.


    Meanwhile, the male now naked awaits; a male steward pushing his way into the open door of the bathroom, is greeted immediately with a kiss, and smiles in delight. This is definitely going to be a homosexual romp.

    The now truly fulfilled female announces the joys of “Müller love.”

 

Los Angeles, February 24, 2026

Reprinted from My Queer Cinema blog (February 2026).

Jason Sakaki | Ramen Boys / 2025

the lifeguard delivers up the slipper

by Douglas Messerli

 

Jason Sakaki (screenwriter and director) Ramen Boys / 2025 [13 minutes]

 

Canadian director Jason Sakaki’s Ramen Boys is a charming but absolutely empty-headed comedy about a recently out Asian boy, Kevin (Brendan Koyanagi), desperately—although maybe not so hopelessly—looking for a dream lover to just walk down his street one day, enter is house, and sweep him off his feet.


    He even lays out his summer’s dreams to his bestie female friend, Marianna Zouzoulas, who when she expresses in her incredulity he explains that he has already spotted a hunky lifeguard James (Johnny Wu) to passes by the house every day at about 3:00. Having questioned him about why he hasn’t called out to him, this Rapunzel in his tower, realizes it is about 3:00 once again, and rushes to his balcony.

    Finally he does call out, but when the lifeguard (recognized as a pool guard by his T-shirt) doesn’t hear him, he tosses a slipper at him, attempting to cover up his blatant come-on making up a story about a huge insect which he was attempting to kill.


    Still, his ludicrous story works like a charm, as the lifeguard visits him to return the shoe. Within minutes, our crazy gay hero has discovered that the big-chested savior is not gay—happily discerning, however, that he is “bi”—and is ready to serve him up a meal of Ramen, the lifeguard quoting Lady Gaga’s off-hand observation: “There could be a hundred Asians in the room, and 99 don’t believe in using a kettle for the ramen. But all it takes is just one who believes.” Even James has to agree that Kevin’s kettle heated ramen is quite special.

    And within moments both boys, feeling it has been very difficult to find the right person who really cares, find themselves kissing and falling in love.

    The film ends in a truly meandering and meaningless scene in which, after Kevin summarizes his wonderful summer with James, the female bestie Marianna begins to explain her special summer with a Greek boy.

     This is lite, very lite fair with a fair amount of cliches and one zinger about Asians meeting up with white gay boys. Most of the white boys who are attracted to Asians, the concur, have just returned from Japan showing pictures of them in a kimono. But these young men are so attractive that you’re happy they’ve found love. Too bad it couldn’t have been in a more intelligent movie.

 

Los Angeles, February 24, 2026 | Reprinted from My Queer Cinema blog (February 2026).

Monday, February 23, 2026

Isaiah Henderson | Balloons / 2025

hot air

by Douglas Messerli

 

Isaiah Henderson (screenwriter and director) Balloons / 2025 [9 minutes]

 

The director of this short student film lets loose with nearly every cliché in Gay Film 101 stock book to tell the tale of two boys, played Keller Kennedy and Braeden Stelle, in a story about a “fleeting romance.” Like boys in love in a thousand short films, they run across the golden-steaked beach, pick up and twirl each other about, and generally grab hold of each other’s body every chance they get. How strange, but I’ve never really seen any man do that in real life.


    But we know something’s up (no pun intended) when writer/directed Henderson suddenly introduces the metaphor of balloons used to symbolically celebrate so many occasions: birthdays, weddings, baby showers, etc. Balloons, so we are told, can are so delicate they can pop at any moment, and rise up only to be trapped in a wire or a tree.

    So too is these boy’s relationship, particularly since we notice one of them constantly looking over his shoulder at nearly every moment to be sure no one’s watching their gay lovemaking. And eventually, we just know it, he will have to say something terribly profound such as “I just can’t do this anymore.”

    He goes out and quickly finds a girlfriend who together make it difficult for the now lonely queer boy just to survive, writing “Faggot” across his dorm door and basically mocking him as he passes by, even if there are moments with his former partner tends to stare after him a little bit longer that disdain permits. We just know that someday he will have to come home to his unhappy wife to declare: “I just can’t go on.”


   Our remaining blond-haired queer has fortunately saved two balloons, one red, one blue so show us at the very last moment, that sometimes balloons do actually “reach the sky.”

     Someone should have clued Henderson in that he was sentimentalizing a trivial affair by using the most tired of cliches. But several commentators on Letterboxd thought this movie was actually quite profound. AcomsDave Community Journalist even gushed: “Isaiah Henderson’s Balloons isn’t just a short film; it’s a gut punch wrapped in eight minutes of raw emotion. If you’ve ever navigated the treacherous waters of a love that’s vibrant behind closed doors but shrouded in fear in public, this one will resonate deeply.”

    So many gay filmmakers and their audiences these days seen to have forgotten that gay boys don’t just hug, run, and kiss on a beach before pouting and slouching off to bed in tears; many of us still think, question, and challenge the world around us in far more complex ways. And a relationship is not always the first thing on our minds.

 

Los Angeles, February 23, 2026

Reprinted from My Queer Cinema blog (February 2026).

 

 

Sunday, February 22, 2026

Gregg Araki | Mysterious Skin / 2004, 2005 US

confusing love

by Douglas Messerli

 

Gregg Araki (screenwriter, based on a work by Scott Heim, and director) Mysterious Skin / 2004, 2005 US

 

A perfect double bill of the gay cinema of abuse might be Marcel Gisler’s 1998 work Fögi Is a Bastard and Araki’s Mysterious Skin, very similar in some ways, except that the early work is about an older boy who willingly enters into an abusive gay relationship perceiving it as a kind of love, while the New Queer Cinema director Araki focuses on pre-adolescent boys, in particular, Neil McCormick (Joseph Gordon-Levitt playing the older version and Chase Ellison playing the younger boy) who also sees it as wanted attention and love instead of abuse. In both cases the affects our similar, both the young boy in Gisler’s work and Neil becoming teenage prostitutes whose future as adults seems unsure and confused. Both boys survive and realize their misunderstandings, although in a strange way still remaining vaguely in love with their abusers.


    The second figure in Araki’s film, Brian Lackey (Brady Corbet) is far more tortured, unable to even remember the one evening of abuse he suffered when Neil introduced him to the Little League baseball coach, which resulted in him being found under a home crawl space, his nose bleeding. Unlike Neil, who immediately identified as a homosexual, Brian seems to have no sexual identity, left with only the feeling that at sometime he has been abducted, perhaps, even by aliens. For all the difficulties of Neil’s life, a few of which I will later recount, at least he is fully cognizant of what has happened to him, and able to even know how he was involved, even if he cannot escape the vortex into which those experiences have thrown him. Brian, whose parents are most neglectful, his father finally leaving the relationship, remembers only a vague rainy afternoon when, after no one picked him up, he awoke in the crawl space, with no memory of the intervening five hours.

    Although there is no question of the abusiveness of Fögi in Gisler’s film, his relationship with the younger boy can still be seen as a kind of confused attempt at love turned dangerous with his use of alcohol and drugs. In Araki’s version the coach is a textbook case of an adult pedophile whose selfish involvement of these young boys in his sexual activities basically destroys their lives, even if Neil confuses the feelings with love.


    In Neil’s case, the boy living with an irresponsible mother whose love of her son almost borders, at times, on the incestual, the coach simply encouraged a young boy’s own sexual confusions, providing him with an older friend living in a house filled with foods and candies loved by children—one might almost say like the witch in Hansel and Gretel—and someone perfectly willing to play child-like games, even tape recording him shouting obscenities. After a ridiculous event of emptying, in a child-like fury, entire boxes of rainbow-colored Fruit Loops over their heads, he engages in sex like it were simply a natural part of childish misbehavior. For Neil it feels good, with him finally at the center of someone’s attention, unlike his father who shows his disappointment with both his son and wife as he scowls away from the house. Neil’s later involvement with prostitution with older men leads almost naturally from his short involvement with the coach before the man leaves town, now clearly fearful that word might get out about his dangerous activities.

    Fortunately, for Neil, he has very early on bonded with a fellow student, Wendy Peterson (Michelle Trachtenberg as the adult and Riley McGuire as the child), almost as wild as he is, to whom he can tell the truth and share his sense of alienation.


     When she moves to New York City, he eventually follows, she having found a job and trying finally to ween him away from the big city horrors of male prostitution. Two events, one in which he is severely beaten by a john and another in which he meets up with a man dying of AIDS who simply hires him to touch him, no sex involved finally bring Neil to his senses, as he finds a job in a subway shop and begins his slow climb back into some normalcy, with Wendy’s help.

    Brian has no such possibility, since he experiences only a void, a strange hole in time that he somehow knows is crucial in comprehending who and what he is. Reading about individuals who claim to have been abducted by aliens, often with a strange blue light and a total loss of memory, he increasingly believes he may have suffered a similar experience, and contacts a young woman, Avalyn Friesen (Mary Lynn Rajskub) who claims just such an abduction.

    She writes him back, inviting her to come visit her not so far away in a nearby Kansas town. From what we see of her isolated conditions and the appearance of her almost mad-looking father, not at all appreciative of his daughter having visitors, she may have been abused by her dad, veiling the experience with the alien story. Araki, however, is not interested in pursuing her experiences, and his film makes no such assumptions. What is important is that Brian finally finds his version of Neil’s Wendy Peterson, and the two bond; she invites him back to witness a dead cow she has discovered, believing that it too is the product of alien acts. Strangely, she encourages him to feel up into its severed intestines which Neil does with a great sense of fascination.

    But when Avalyn suddenly shows up at his doorstep with the secret intentions of making love to him, he is horrified. What the childhood experience has left him, perhaps, is a kind of horror of sex, particularly with a female.

    Brian has also been encouraged to reach into his dreams, in which a young boy in a baseball uniform often appears. Through a bit of research, he is able to find a picture of the baseball team, spotting a boy who looks vaguely like the one in his dream, Neil McCormick.

     Coincidentally, Neil has promised to his mother to return home for Christmas, and does so, just after the incident I mention above, when he is beaten by a client. He tells his mother that he has been beaten and robbed at the airport.


   And finally, when the two boys meet up, Brian begging Neil to help him remember what has happened, the slightly older boy takes him to the house, now owned by others, where the coach once lived. Since the family is out, it being the Christmas season, the boys break in a back way, and Neil shows him the room where everything happened. With Neil’s help Brian is able to restore his memory, how the boys visited the coach together, where encouraged to have sex with one another, and finally were asked to fistfuck the coach, which explains Brian’s fascination with innards of the cow. Finally, he realizes the awful truth, laying his head down in tears on Neil’s lap as carolers, hearing people within the house, begin to sing “Silent Night.”


     If Gisler’s work allows some equivocation regarding Fögi’s behavior, Araki makes it perfectly clear how the abusing coach has helped to destroy these young boys’ early lives. We can only hope that they can now begin to heal themselves. But the crime is just that, childhood abuse that can effect children far beyond their formative years. And what isn't brought up again in the story, is another scene in which Neil equally abused Brian on Halloween by setting off fireworks held in the boy's mouth; the abused often go on to abuse others as well.

    The director was also careful to let all his audiences know that the younger child actors were not present in any of the scenes with suggested abuse or spoke of the adult themes of the cinema. What he did was create two scripts, one completely innocent with daily proofs approved by the children’s parents. Their actions, however, often accorded with the ones he used in the different context of the film itself and were slipped into the more complex adult story, without any direct interchange with the actual dialogue.

     Critics praised the film for its brilliant handling of such difficult scenes, and psychologists such as Richard Gartner proclaimed it as an accurate portrayal of the long-term effects of abused boys.      

     To me the work appeared just a little too ploddingly obvious in its inevitable spin into where the abuse left these children as their grew into young men. Of the two, I found Neil’s trajectory to be far more interesting and intelligent than Brian’s whose current sexuality is left vague, and whose character left me a bit confused of how the void in time and his recurring nose bleeds could play such a dominating role in his youthful life. Perhaps Araki could have given him a bit more complexity instead of letting him simply wander off into the land of hoaxes.

     It still, however, remains a strong piece of film-making daring to engage a subject most directors would not dare. Once more, I encourage the double viewing with Gisler’s film which brings even a clearer focus of the variances of abuse.

 

Los Angeles, February 22, 2026

Reprinted from My Queer Cinema blog (February 2026).     

 

Index O-Z

Dave O'Brien Straight Boys / 2005 Nick Oceano El primo ( The Cousin ) / 2008  Ken Ochiai Phoenix / 2006 Carlos Ocho Relación Abierta ...