Friday, November 20, 2026

Charlie Polinger | A Place to Stay / 2018

no exit

by Douglas Messerli

 

Charlie Polinger (screenwriter and director) A Place to Stay / 2018 [17 minutes]

 

American director Charlie Polinger’s film is a rather moody, endearing movie about closeted gay life in 1959 Kansas City, a seemingly intelligent drama, unless you try to make sense of it.

    We all know that numerous LGBTQ figures were forced into dark, very deep closets during the 1950s when in many states it was illegal to be gay and gay activity often led to arrest. Gordon (Will Beinbrink) is evidently such a person, who having temporary escaped his stifling St. Louis suburban world where he worked as a lawyer, is suddenly summoned back.


     The big question, however, is how has he managed to stay in Kansas City long enough to have a job as a drag queen in a nightclub and a boyfriend Andy (Paul Iacono) almost young enough to be his son; and why if he’s been summoned back to St. Louis does he return without even bothering to make up some excuse to his young friend?

      Let us imagine that Gordon regularly commutes, disappearing for vague reasons from his other life in order to maintain his Kansas City self. But a lawyer working in an office is not exactly a traveling salesman. And apparently he’s been around Andy long enough to call their little apartment “a place to stay” while developing a real kinship with his audience at the nightclub where he performs? In short, the situation is fascinating and all too real, but Polinger has forgotten how to make it logically come together

     On top of that, how could anybody leading such a double life—we soon discover Gordon is married to Rose (Breeda Wool) and has two young boys and girl—be stupid enough to leave behind a letter with his home address fully written out.


     Why when Andy discovers that his older lover has been lying to him and is suffocating in a world where it’s clear things are about to explode, would he want to invite himself to dinner, sitting through the torture of an evening with the clearly lonely, heavily drinking Rose? And how might even the craziest of young boys want such a lover back and be willing to even reveal that lover’s absurd duplicity through a photo he’s taken.


      We are simply dropped into a moment of insanity in which all the parties have lost their sense of credibility. Gordon, cornered, somehow still believes he can maintain the lie. Rose, who clearly suspects something is amiss which is made even more obvious when her husband locks himself in their bedroom with the boy to slug some sense into him, and comes out of it all with lipstick on his lips implanted by the boy’s last kiss, simply wipes the lipstick off. And Andy, with nowhere else to go, with evidently no source of income and no one to turn to, drives back in a rainstorm from whence he came.


     This is a perfect moment of melodrama, which Douglas Sirk might have turned into a feature film. But as viewers, given the fact we cannot even make sense of how Gordon has gotten away it all, we can’t imagine what might come next. Will Rose ask him for a full explanation. Will the now chastened Gordon, still obviously in love with Andy, spill his guts? Will Andy just slip off into the dark never to be see again?  

    Somebody has some explaining to do and it’s not the confused characters, none of whom have a logical way out.

    Perhaps we should start all over again, making up our story as we go along. Perhaps Gordon had attempted to leave his wife and boys, to start over in a life where he felt more at home, living for several months or even a year in what he described to Andy as “a place to stay.” But then the guilt of leaving, his love for his children, and even his distress over the abandonment of normality was just too much for him to bear. He returned home vowing to try harder, to start over again just as I have with my imaginary tale.

     But still the characters remain trapped in space, locked into their last cinematic actions: Gordon with face down in despair as Rose wipes the lipstick off his mouth. Andy off to nowhere. Where can anyone go from here? Back to Kansas City? Will tipsy Rose, now knowing something about what her husband has been doing in his absence, finally demand a divorce? Sirk would have known what to do, but he’s dead. And, as much as I like to write plays, I refuse to pretend to serve as a script doctor for some poor film student. Charlie Polinger has trapped his characters into a space as deadly as they might truly have been as living beings in 1959, in a world of “no exit.”

 

Los Angeles, September 11, 2023

Reprinted from World Cinema Review (September 2023).

No comments:

Post a Comment

Index O-Z

Dave O'Brien Straight Boys / 2005 Nick Oceano El primo ( The Cousin ) / 2008  Ken Ochiai Phoenix / 2006 Carlos Ocho Relación Abierta ...