symbiosis
by Douglas Messerli
Pascal Latil (screenplay and director) La
dérade (The Drift) / 2011 [13 minutes]
A handsome young man, Simon (Yoann Moëss),
lies on the beach, watching his lover François (Adrien Stasiulis) return from a
swim in the ocean. The swimmer suggests that his friend should take a swim, but
he is more than reticent, taking the time instead to recall when they were last
on the beach, over year and a half ago. As usual he had not wanted to go, but
once he got there, he enjoyed it and found the day most pleasurable.
“Afterwards, I was happy. But things were never the same after that.”
The
small talk is almost all one-sided, with memories dominating. But we have
already been pulled into the story. Why have things never been the same? They
do not seem particularly estranged. Is the man on the beach ill?
In
the very next frame, we perceive that, in fact, that is the case. Simon in is
bed, with his mother (Valérie Vogt) trying to get him to eat. François, she
tells him, has just called. He is on his way, but Simon doesn’t want him to
know—“what” we are not yet told.
When François arrives, he appears to know that Simon is not well, that
he has not been able to sleep. He visits with Simon and then prepares dinner
for Babette, Simon’s mother.
Back at the beach Simon explains that it was true he could not sleep,
that he missed François, who we soon discover is a sailor who is gone for long
stretches at a time. Simon recalls now—through a visual reenactment—how they
wrestled on the beach that long ago day, and how is heart suddenly gave out as
began to cough, insisting that he was fine. But we observe that it was then
that the illness, a heart condition we soon learn, began.
In
the lovers’ home, François makes pork with honey
and curry for Simon’s mother Babette, a meal she loves. But he is troubled. He
is again on call for a voyage to South Africa which he cannot contractually
escape, and is worried about Simon’s illness. It may be his last voyage but we
will be away several months. Naturally, he is frightened that something might
happen to Simon while he is gone. She is happy for their relationship and tells
François that Simon has told her that he is happy the two have made friends so
that if something happens to him, she will be able to explain it all to his
lover.
On the beach Simon comments on how strange he
must have looked when he, a literature student, was told by François that he was having an affair with a sailor,
almost like a cliché. But François wonders if he really feared that he was
stupid, suggesting he has always been able read Simon like an open book. And
their lovely symbiosis hints of something else that we have not yet confirmed.
But the very next moment, commenting on the past,
François is still amazed at the way Simon hid his true condition from him.
He could have won an Oscar, he suggests.
“I didn’t want to lie to you. I just wanted us to be happy.”
In a return to the past, the phone rings, Babette answering it. A heart
has been found, the perfect donor, and she is told to prepare Simon for the
operation in Brest.
And then he got better, he tells François in the present time on the
beach. “You were sailing in South Africa and I was getting better.” He kept
imagining when they might again be together, fighting to survive for that
moment.
“But then somebody had to tell me that it was you, the guy on the
highway who was in the crash, and the new heart beating in my chest was yours.”
Finally, what we suspected is revealed, the student of literature has
now re-created his sailor in a fantasy world beyond death, where in his own
body is the heart of his lover helps him to continue to live—but now so very,
very alone. Or perhaps not. As Simon says to his fantasy lover, “Yes but, you
are here, and you’re not, and I talk to you, and I can’t touch you.” His François reassures him that he has given him the best
gift ever, “The rest of your life.”
The beach where Simon sits playing out these memories, we discover, is
the dock where François left with his ship. François goes back in for a swim;
we watch him move towards the waters once more. And then he is not there. Simon
is alone with him in his heart, his heart in him. The symbiosis between the two
is nearly perfect except that it is tragically empty of the physicality that
most defines human love.
Los Angeles, December 22, 2022
Reprinted from World Cinema Review (December
2022).





No comments:
Post a Comment