at the core
by
Douglas Messerli
Gary Halvorson and Lileana Blain-Cruz (directors) Lincoln at the Bardo / 2026 [Metropolitan Opera-HD live production]
With
a libretto by Royce Vavrek (based on the fiction of the same name by George
Saunders), a score by Missy Mizzoli, and directed on stage by Lileana
Blain-Cruz, Lincoln at the Bardo opened with great acclaim on October
19, 2026. Audiences appeared to adore the production, and critics such George
Grella, writing in New York Classical Review delighted in the Met’s
first commissioned opera from a female composer:
“The
result is a fertile combination of creative minds and material. Saunders’ novel
is populated with multiple characters speaking and thinking in multiple voices—
almost begging for a set of singers—and Mazzoli is one of the most talented, if
not always consistent, living opera composers. Throw in the fantastical nature
of the story, and there’s a good possibility for some magic to happen.
And there was magic on the stage Monday
night, including an enviable cast that includes baritone Peter Mattei as
Lincoln, mezzo-soprano Stephanie Blythe, countertenor Anthony Roth Costanzo,
bass-baritone Ryan McKinny, and soprano Janai Brugger. There were prosaic
moments as well, some from the story itself, and some from the adaptation by
Mazzoli and librettist Royce Vavrek.”
Writing in The New Yorker Nathan
Heller in his essay “A Song of Grief and Union in Lincoln in the Bardo” suggests
that Mazzoli and Vavrek delivered a “charismatic, openhearted work”..that
deliver in “the form of a comedy with a melancholy guise.” Praising Mizzoli’s music,
in particular, he writes:
“In
Lincoln in the Bardo she has produced a rich twenty-first-century score
with musical shadows of both the Civil War era and the Halloween graveyard,
opening with a spooky stacked minor tone cluster (made spookier by knitting
needles rattling the percussion) and extending to gorgeous snatches of chocolatey
writing in the low brass, befitting a bereaved President. The orchestra, under
the direction of Yannick Nézet-Séguin, comes at the music with terrific
confidence, delivering the wort of fully conceived performance that rarely
awaits brand-new work…. The intelligence of her dramatic writing haunts the score.
She make much of big glissandos, in which the men and women of the chorus slide
together through a scale, like a winding siren. Heading upward, these slides
impart moments of ecstatic, unworldly levitation. Send downward, they plummet
us into the earth.”
Commenting on the cast, critic David
Salazar, writing in OperaWire comments on strong performances from the
young boy, Everett Sobers, who plays Lincoln’s recently dead son Willie to Christine
Goerke’s “pants” performance as the Reverend. He describes the latter
performance as “her most impressive performance at the Met to date, the voice
clear, elegant, and potent in the space. There was delicacy mixed with a more
sardonic edge throughout the Act two monologue and tenderness in the
interactions with Willie. But that aside, and perhaps most impressive was that
I didn’t recognize Goerke onstage. The costume design by Montana Levi Blanco
and makeup team did tremendous heavy lifting here, but Goerke’s physicality
must also be spotlighted and commended. She was not just playing a character
but viscerally inhabiting it.”
Other performances he praises include Ryan
McKinny and Jonah Hoskins, who “proved a tremendous duo, playing off each other
well, their voices melding well with one another. Ditto for Stephanie Blythe
and Craig Colclough as the bickering couple whose more accented singing added a
unique texture to the soundscape.”
“Joshua Blue had a revelatory performance
as Thomas Havens, not only with the precision of his aria’s faster sections,
but also gentle legato he displayed in its second half. During all of his
appearances, he let his honeyed tenor shine with ease and he brought a
tranquility and longing to the musical mosaic. In the final scene of the opera,
during which the three Black characters commune with Lincoln and declare their
hope for a better future, his voice coalesced well with Mattei’s.”
He closes this section of his essay: “I
didn’t forget about Peter Mattei as Lincoln. It’s surprising that for a story
in which he is the titular character, how peripheral he seems to the
proceedings. He effectively has a handful of scenes and doesn’t sing much in
some of them, but his presence looms large, literally and figuratively. We
await his arrival. Willie pines for his return. Characters scheme around that
return. And eventually, he comes to the realization that he has to accept his
son’s death. His arc mirrors Willie’s in this way (again, brilliant story
structure). I can’t imagine anyone else besides Mattei in this role. Not only
is the baritone’s physical nature perfect for the famously tall
Commander-in-Chief, but his calm and collected demeanor, coupled with a
flawless voice, is nothing short of Presidential. His singing, while composed,
was full of stinging melancholy. As he wept for his song and repeated his ‘I
promise,’ you could sense the composure breaking, the pain giving way. But the
most powerful moments came at the close – as he comes to terms with how broken
everyone is, Mattei lets his Lincoln weep and the falsetto evocations of ‘Willie
is dead,’ were the most affecting moment of the entire night. Credit Mazzoli
for taking the risk to write that vocal line and Mattei for pulling them off
with such care and vulnerability.”
And these are just a sampling of the
positive reviews.
I was finally able to see the free
HD-production on YouTube on its next to last day, offered instead of in the usual theater setting, since it was
not originally scheduled as a regular filmed production, the Metropolitan
quickly realizing with the great success of their opening that they had perhaps
made a mistake in not putting it on their regular schedule, although one might
suppose they originally felt that its subject matter and plot were far too
strange for that venue. But they quickly corrected their miscalculation, and
used the HD-performance, instead, as a fund-raising effort, providing those of
us unable to see the New York production an opportunity to experience this operatic
masterwork.
And yes, I too was enthralled and almost
mesmerized by the beauty of the music, singing, puppetry by James Ortiz, the
sets by Adam Rigg, and the special effects by Jeremy Chernick, as well as the
always wonderful Met chorus.
The plot is another thing. And when I say
that, I am not inferring that it too wasn’t totally engaging and involving,
wondrous most of the time, and absolutely astounding at others. But one has too
admit that Lincoln at the Bardo has one of the weirdest stories of all
opera history. Moreover, the story in this case is told in a manner quite
unusual to most operas, embedded as they generally are in deep historic events
or in the case more modern operas, characters that are early on delineated in
the first act by the text.
Rather, in this work almost all is linear,
one tale told after the other in succession, so that it is not until the end
that we can truly tie the pieces laid out before us together. It is not that
history as no role in this opera. Lincoln and the Civil War, obviously, stand substantially
as a backdrop against which the events of the work occur. But given the strange
and other-worldly placement of the numerous figures we meet, except for at the
end of the second act, they seem almost out of touch with that grounding. And,
in fact, despite the fact that Lincoln’s love, loss, and grieving for son are
at the heart of the work, they seem almost incidental in their linear thrust to
the war which is never discussed in any detail, but relies on our own knowledge
of what that war meant.
Perhaps the aperture is something acquired
as an award only after his meaninglessly chaste life. But the joke seems somewhat
course and pointless given his story and confuses us at the very beginning of
the opera about the tone of the rest of the piece. As anyone who knows my
writing will tell you, I am anything but prudish or moralistic. But here I just
feel that the opera began in a direction that, fortunately, it never pursued.
Suddenly seeing Willie standing on the top
of his burial tomb, they are both shocked. Both live in what they perceive as
the Bardo, a place were the sick go to get well, perceiving their own graves
simply as recuperating beds. Everyone in the Bardo has a story to tell and
hopes to get well enough to return back to normal life. But what they do
immediately perceive is that the Bardo, with its many dangers of tendrils, horrific
tales, and hauntings is not the place for a young boy.
Bevins and Vollman, who become central to
the plot, fetch the Reverend (Goerke), who we discover in the second act is the
only one in the Bardo—the traditional Tibetan limbo between life and the
afterlife—who knows that they are all actually dead. He has experienced the
judgment and been found not worthy, despite his life of piety and supposedly
good deeds; instead of facing his fate in this strangely Christian
interpretation of judgment and damnation, he turns and runs, ending up, like
all the others in a world of horror.
Yet, he does do good deeds here, if
nothing else by helping give advice and succor to those who believe they will
soon recover and return to life.
Together, the three of them try to convince
the boy that he should not tarry in the Bardo, but should accept his fate and
leave them. In an effort to show him one of the worst instances of what might
happen, they determine to take him on a visit to Miss Elise Traynor. But on the
way they first run into the Barons (Stephanie Blythe and Craig Colclough) a couple
who have spent their lives as drunkards, not even keeping their eyes on their
own children. When they finally go on search of a missing son, lost somewhere
in the crowds, they are run over by a carriage, both of them dying in the
process.
This raucous couple, partly in recompense
for their guilt for their children having suddenly found themselves with either
father or mother, despise children, further scarring little Willie. But the young
boy is determined to wait it out for his father to come for him.
Even worse than the Hodges is Miss Elise
Traynor, performed in mad drag by Anthony Roth Costanzo. Countertenor Costanzo
is one of my very favorite opera performers, a true pioneer who performed a
scene in the nude in Philip Glass’ opera Akhnaten. He he is here willing
to go way off the score in his howling rendition of a 14-year-old girl, now
entangled in the cemetery tendrils and by the memories of hands, pigs, and
other beings and objects which appear from time-to-time from under her vast
dress. Some critics did not approve of his performance, Salazar, for example,
describing it as a voice “that filled the hall even though there was an unevenness
to his approach which oscillated between straight tone to notably wide vibrato
on some phrases.” But he is said to have performed the highest note in this
performance ever heard on the Met stage, and I can only applaud his approach as
appropriate for a young woman furious for dying of a fever before she has had
any of the opportunities to experience marriage or motherhood.
Suddenly a choir of angels appears
encouraging all to accept the “MatterLightBloom” which will send them to their
proper destinations. Bevins and Vollman suggest to Willie that the best thing
he can do is simply duck as if he were in a World War I trench during a blitz,
and wait it out. On this trip Willie is almost convinced to join the angels,
but sees his father returning to his mausoleum and runs to greet him.
Lincoln (Mattei), disconsolate with the
death of his beloved son, holds what he believes is his child in his arms.
Frustrated that to the boy it looks as if he were speaking and holding only a
worm, he slips through his father’s empty arms and attempts to console him.
The others notice “the profound intimacy”
between the two, having nearly forgotten what it was like to hold and touch others,
and they are sincerely moved by the situation. They also recognize who Willie’s
father is, Lincoln, the president himself. Willie is able to perceive his
father’s inner thoughts where he hears his father insist he will return.
Willie remains in the Bardo, accordingly, in
the beginning of the 2nd, shorter act, but by now the tendrils have captured
him. Lincoln returns and in tears lifts the body of his son from his grave, as the men struggle to free the boy from the
fast growing vines. Before they can do so, however, Lincoln has again wandered
off.
While they are gone, the Reverend reveals
his long story of how he came upon his destination with the afterlife along with
a ginger chap and a doodling Pennsylvanian. He now realizes that only if he
himself accepts the “MatterLightBloom” will the boy be able to follow his
example, and in a burst of pyrotechnics he is gone.
The duo do wind their way into the president’s
consciousness and succeed in bringing him back to the boy, who freed from the
tendrils sits to talk with his father on a nearby bench.
He soon after crawls into his lap, finally
able to hear his father’s full thoughts. As Lincoln recalls his son’s illness
and passing, the boy comes to comprehend that he is already dead, unable to
return home. And as his father finally realizes that he can no longer hold on
to someone or something that is gone, Willie feels totally freed, delighted to
know that he is already dead and free to join the choirs of angels. He
celebrates this with the news the entire bardo community, who in the process
finally come recognize that they too must be dead and can be freed through the light
offered them.
As Bevins and Vollman watch Willie
transcend through the glorious fireworks, they convince Miss Traynor to join
them also in the “MatterLightBlooming,” the entire stage now coming to life as
flashes of light.
He now feels Lincoln’s presence as he
passes and, like Willie, is able to share with the President the necessity of
continuing the painful Civil War to help free men like him so that they can
become engaged in the society. Litzie herself suddenly comes to life, singing a
glorious aria to the possibilities for those like herself.
Indeed, Havens appears to have now become
one with the President, as he goes off with him on his black stallion, the
opera coming to an end, as the Bardo returns, at least temporarily, to simply
being a memorial to the dead, instead a world of sorrow and desire to return to
mankind.
The strange work, just by its linear push,
finally pushes us into new territory. One could only wish that librettist Royce
Vavrek were poet enough to help elevate the story with his language. But
unfortunately, like so many contemporary librettists, he is stuck in the
vernacular and cannot seem, accept for moments at a time, to escape the
limitations of everyday speech, often simply repeating words, almost like a
stutterer, that only reiterates the problems of the work’s linearity, rather
than helping it interweave the poetry of the world they have left behind with
their own lives, which might have created a deeper sense of history.
The repetitions might be appropriate for
the 14-year-old Miss Elise Traynor or even the fixated Mrs. Hodge. But
certainly Lincoln, the Reverend, and even Vollman and Bevins should have been
able to speak, at least for a few moments each, in a more magical language that
didn’t simply delineate plot. Only Havens and perhaps Litzie seem, in the end,
to find something of depth about which they can sing.
My complaints do not mean that the work
isn’t a true success; all operas have their faults, the very impossibility of
so many different elements coming fully together in such a form being obvious. This
opera is already close—in its odd pairing of story with the themes of loss,
despair, and the desire for the dead to remain with the living that lie at the
core of all of us—to being a true classic.
Note: All
but the two first photographs above were provided the Metropolitan Opera
Company for reviewers, photographed by Karen Almond.
Los
Angeles, November 19, 2026
Reprinted
from My Queer Cinema blog (November 2026).





















