transformation into what?
by Douglas Messerli
Max Kutschenreuter (director) Dixie
/ 2017 [5 minutes]
From the few descriptions I have read
about this film on the internet, no one quite seems what to make of this
fantastical work by Netherlands director Max Kutschenreuter. I must admit, I
don’t quite know how to describe it either.
Gay Films Matters categorizes it simply as a drama, but usually in order
for a drama to occur, at least as I comprehend it, you need some sort of
dialogue. Here there is none.
Google’s AI moves into quite illogical territory, imagining it as
representing “a transition between adolescence and adulthood from the
perspective of an LGBT character, while also suggesting it is about a gay
teenager who “navigates how he fits into the gay scene.” What drugged-out
critic helped the AI computer cook up these descriptions, I can’t imagine.
Film Freeway describes it perhaps
the most aptly: “A young man goes through a transformation after meeting a
group of drag queens in a public toilet.”
The
young man (Franz Marius Lüttig), with little indication of desire or seeking,
is simply walking his bicycle down what I presume is an Amsterdam street.
Suddenly out of a streetside port-a-potty, six drag queens (Mazy Mazeltov,
Collete Verbena, Scarlet Turner, Anastasia, Minnie North, and Goldie Vollhorn) come
stumbling out a bit like circus clowns from a toy auto. Seeing the startled,
but definitely good-looking young man, they form a kind of witch-like circle
and without a word begin to dance in a definitely drugged-out manner.
Before long they circle him, a couple of the queens reaching out to
touch his torso; and before you know it, the young man, now with shirt stripped
away—and played by Marvin Baudach—begins the ridiculous act of posing and
flexing like a muscle-man contestant.
Obviously, the attention of the queens imbues him with some secret male
power. They dance around him a few more times and eventually trail off.
Just as suddenly we are returned to the original young man who picks up
his previously dropped bicycle and goes walking off to the main street.
Is the film suggesting that these queens are simply more powerful as men
because they are willing to abandon their male characteristics? I think that
would take a stretch of the imagination.
In short, even if I don’t quite know what the message of this little
fantasy is, I certainly don’t find it very pleasing or appropriate to queer
reality. It does not at all suggest, to my way of thinking, that this young
man, turned into a mini-Arnold Schwarzenegger finds any place in the gay
community except outside it and the cramped toilet world from where these nighttime
monsters have been tossed up.
I think you can skip this vague and not very carefully thought-out
5-minute work.
Los Angeles, November 18, 2026
Reprinted from My Queer Cinema blog
(November 2026).



No comments:
Post a Comment