Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Juan Sebastián Torales | Almamula (Carnal Sins) / 2023

in the wilderness of innocent love

by Douglas Messerli

 

Juan Sebastián Torales (screenwriter and director) Almamula (Carnal Sins) / 2023

 

Argentine director Juan Sebastián Torales’s feature film Almamula begins at the point the most movies cataloguing homophobia put much later into their plots with two 12-year young boys, Nino (Nicolás Díaz) and his friend, hiding in a warehouse as outside a gang of young boys shout out slurs, obviously in reaction to what they have perceived having been engaged in homosexual sexual acts. We don’t know if that was actually the case, or whether as 12-year-olds are prone to do, they were just experimenting. But we do sense, when Nino asks the other boy for a kiss before he makes a run for it, that Nino is far-more interested in the event than was his friend.


     Nino continues in hiding, but is soon discovered, severely beaten until he passes out, and tossed into an abandoned truck filled with toads. Soon after, the other boy’s family, along with neighbors, visit Nino’s mother, Estela (María Soldi) and his father Ernesto (Cali Coronel) insisting that Nino is a bad influence and demanding his removal from school and other situations which involve their own boys.

     Given such a resounding homophobic response in the community, his parents have no other choice but move the entire family to the rural village of Santiago del Estero, where Ernesto has a small house where he lives most of the year when he is away as the head of a logging firm. Moving into a world without central cooling and abutting the jungle which Ernesto and his men are gradually cutting away, Estela and their daughter Natalia bitterly complain about conditions, but they know there is no other choice in order to protect their son.


     Nino is taken out of school and put into the hands of the local priest who is preparing a class of native children and those of the landowners who are all about Nino’s age for confirmation. Estela, frankly, is happy to have someone monitoring Nino’s moral behavior, which the priest does for all of his young flock, particularly the boys, threatening them with his pious tales of Christian damnation along with the local mythologies of the female forest spirit, Almamula, who captures young boys who unclean minds and spirits. Just before Nino and his family has arrived, in fact, their servant Maria’s son Panchito has disappeared in the jungle, never to return, obviously a sinful boy who the monster has spirited off. Understandably, Ernesto declares the jungle, with its snakes, falling trees, and legendary spirits, off limits.

      Obviously such a declaration makes trips to the jungle necessary for a confused young man, unable to comprehend his urges and terrified for what they represent. The more he is preached to, the more his adolescent hormones rebel, and even the naked Christ of the cross becomes a masturbatory icon.

       Free from these tensions, so it seems, are the hypocrisies of Nino sister and her parents. Her sister, a few years older, and her friends are exploring lesbian sex with one another until Natalia begins sneaking off for heterosexual sex with one of her father’s beefy workers.


      The gentle worker, Malevo (Beto Frágola) is asked to help her fix the living room fan and other tasks, with a growing sexual tension between the two emanating particularly from Estela, since her husband is off for days in jungle on jobs.

       Hearing of the legend of Almamula, Nino pulls out a painting his grandmother once did of the terrifying figure and posts first a crucifix and later the painting on a jungle tree, demanding that one or the other fetch him and take him away from the isolated world he now inhabits, and where even the slightest of infractions (masturbation itself seen as sin by the priest and church) are punishable in one form or another. For a boy having homosexual feelings on top of his normal teenage sexual angst, it is nearly unbearable.

      At one point, Malevo summons him out of room, and pulls him into the jungle to jack him off. Nino is rightfully horrified, but also aroused and more than a little interested in the man who seems so fearless in a society of moral hypocrisy. And over the course of the film Malevo becomes a kind of mentor to the boy, taking him in more as a friend than as a pedophilic object when Nino most needs it.

     Yet, as reviewer Jennie Kermode observed in Eye for Film:

 

“It is men like this whom he fantasies about in scenes which may inspire concern in viewers, because he is still a child, and for all we know, one of them may have taken Panchito. Whilst the church community may think it is protecting the boy, his inability to talk to anybody about his desires makes him very vulnerable. It’s a lonely, difficult coming of age, and one which gradually leads him to identify with the otherness of the forest—a place which is also under threat.”

 

     Although director Torales hints at supernatural forces in the jungle, and occasionally Nino hears a sound or glimpses of what seems to be a running figure, the film stays very much within the realm of naturalism. Indeed, the most horrific and shocking moment of the movie comes when Nino enters a clearing only to see his father and the loggers dressed in masks, their faces chalk-white from the dust of tree bark standing, like ghouls, alongside the gigantic machines which are raping the woods. The church says nothing about this immoral action, choosing to focus instead on the genitals of 12-year-old boys.

     When in confession, Nino admits to his fantasies of the naked Christ, he is immediately dragged off to a shed and locked away, his mother called. She, in turn, is distressed than her son only seems to be growing worse, blaming her husband for not being father who was there for him.


     Despite returning to a few days of normalcy, the child goes missing again, this time hanging out with Malevo by the nearby ocean inlets where he fishes with other men of the area, their only source of healthy food.

     Brought home again, and put to work among his father’s loggers as punishment, he asks the maid María what her son Panchito had done that was so awful that he needed to be sent away. Her answer is only that Nino has not sinned enough.

     By this time, however, we have come to realize that perhaps the only truly innocent figure in this film is Nino in his search for his honest feelings, while others all pretend piety but fornicate, cheat, terrorize, and destroy under the cover of their moral pretenses. If this Argentinian Babadook actually comes for Nino, it will surely be to protect the saintly sinner instead of destroy him.


     Forced, finally, to participate in the confirmation exercises, Nino once more walks off the moment the ceremony his over, checking under the loincloth of the huge Christ her mother has had carved for the occasion before eventually wandering back into the jungle.


    There, for the first time, he observes in the near distance a figure, a young boy like him, with sunlight streaming down upon him. Is it Panchito come back just for him, a vision, a hallucination, a fantasy of someone, like himself, with whom in the future he can feel safe? No answer is given. It is up for each of us, as it is for Nino, to make meaning of things out of the time and space in which one is temporarily trapped.

       The situation calls up two previous opposing cinematic possibilities: Alan Clarke’s highly spiritual and almost nationalistically mystical Penda’s Fen (1974) or the far more realistic movie, although magical in its own way, Fuoco Maria Balduzzi Wolves (2016). Neither seems quite appropriate, but if I had to choose I’d have it go in a direction closer to the Balduzzi film, the boys living happily in a wilderness of their innocent love.

 

Los Angeles, July 24, 2023

Reprinted from World Cinema Review (July 2023).

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Titles Index A-N

https://myqueercinema.blogspot.com/2023/12/former-index-to-world-cinema-review.html Films discussed (listed alphabetically by director) [F...