by Douglas Messerli
Mel Carvalho and Lucas Drummond (screenplay), Caio Scot (director) Depois
Daquela Festa (After That Party) / 2019 [15 minutes]
Of the dozen films I discuss in the collection of essays, “Family
Secrets,” Brazilian director Caio Scot’s After that
Party is the only truly comic presentation of family sexual secrets,
reflecting as it does a far more contemporary viewpoint which we hope now
dominates open societies.
This story is really quite
simple. Leo (Lucas Drummond) and his long-time girlfriend (Mel Carvalho)—with
whom, oddly since it has no reason to appear in this tale except as a kind of
quirky aside, he evidently doesn’t have sex—attend a party at which, quite by
accident, they both witness Leo’s father (Charles Fricks) in attendance kissing
another man.
The shock of the scene
momentarily sends Leo reeling, having to leave the party immediately to
contemplate the situation. His girlfriend pushes him quickly to try to express
his true feeling about the incident, and it appears that he is not so upset
because he has discovered that his widowed father is now gay, but that he
hasn’t told him. The two, father and son, have long been close, and Leo still
lives at home with his dad.
Although the discovery does not seem to
be particularly momentous with regard to his love for his father, he and his
girlfriend feel it necessary to relieve his father of his secret by revealing
their new awareness of the situation. The question is simply how to go about
it, and Leo spends a sleepless night in creating a scenario over a meal of
lasagna where he might bring up the subject by discussing his father’s job as
an advertising executive before turning it to a discussion of his friends,
their off-hour activities, and whether or not he meets others outside of his
co-workers, etc. until he can zero in on the particularities which might lead
to the revelation.
Unfortunately, his father serves stroganoff, not their usual Friday
night meal, and their conversation is interrupted by a telephone message before
it can even begin.
So too, he now suggests,
he argues his father needn’t feel that he has done anything wrong in the fact
that the son has witnessed at the very same party that Leo and his girlfriend
attended, his father embrace and kiss a stranger.
For a moment the father attempts to deny it, but quickly becomes speechless. When he regains his composure, he explains that he never cheated or lied to Leo’s mother and loved her dearly. But suddenly he has found an unexpected love with another human being who just happens to be a man. But there was simply no way he could explain it to Leo for fear that he would misunderstand the situation.
Scot’s film feels a little
too much like a liberal school-room advocation of open minds and free talk
about sexuality. But the script, written by the two actors playing Leo and his
girlfriend, at moments is delightfully manic in the son’s attempts to arrange
for that open and free conversation between father and son, resulting in Scot’s
work being a lot of fun, even if we know the final “feel-good” results. Surely
there are a great many Leos and dads out there who have been shaped, post
Stonewall, by the general acceptance of LGBTQ behavior in liberal societies
worldwide. But, alas, I am afraid that they still do not represent the majority
of households. On the very same day I am writing about this film, I have also
just watched director/producer Aiman Hasani’s Dutch film Khata (2019) in
which a couple of teenage brothers, trapped into male prostitution and with
nowhere else to turn, are denied entry into the own home by their parents upon
their discovery of their boys’ secret vocations, which only closes off their
final possible route of escape. Indeed, this film might also have been included
in these pages except that I felt it was more centered on their involvement in
gay prostitution which I will feature in an upcoming essay, “Working Boys.”
But it’s a delight to watch
a work in which family secrets do not necessarily result in terrifying
consequences.
Los Angeles, September 21, 2021
Reprinted from World Cinema Review (September 2021).



No comments:
Post a Comment