Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Juan Sebastián Torales | Almamula (Carnal Sins) / 2023

in the wilderness of innocent love

by Douglas Messerli

 

Juan Sebastián Torales (screenwriter and director) Almamula (Carnal Sins) / 2023

 

Argentine director Juan Sebastián Torales’s feature film Almamula begins at the point the most movies cataloguing homophobia put much later into their plots with two 12-year young boys, Nino (Nicolás Díaz) and his friend, hiding in a warehouse as outside a gang of young boys shout out slurs, obviously in reaction to what they have perceived having been engaged in homosexual sexual acts. We don’t know if that was actually the case, or whether as 12-year-olds are prone to do, they were just experimenting. But we do sense, when Nino asks the other boy for a kiss before he makes a run for it, that Nino is far-more interested in the event than was his friend.


     Nino continues in hiding, but is soon discovered, severely beaten until he passes out, and tossed into an abandoned truck filled with toads. Soon after, the other boy’s family, along with neighbors, visit Nino’s mother, Estela (María Soldi) and his father Ernesto (Cali Coronel) insisting that Nino is a bad influence and demanding his removal from school and other situations which involve their own boys.

     Given such a resounding homophobic response in the community, his parents have no other choice but move the entire family to the rural village of Santiago del Estero, where Ernesto has a small house where he lives most of the year when he is away as the head of a logging firm. Moving into a world without central cooling and abutting the jungle which Ernesto and his men are gradually cutting away, Estela and their daughter Natalia bitterly complain about conditions, but they know there is no other choice in order to protect their son.


     Nino is taken out of school and put into the hands of the local priest who is preparing a class of native children and those of the landowners who are all about Nino’s age for confirmation. Estela, frankly, is happy to have someone monitoring Nino’s moral behavior, which the priest does for all of his young flock, particularly the boys, threatening them with his pious tales of Christian damnation along with the local mythologies of the female forest spirit, Almamula, who captures young boys who unclean minds and spirits. Just before Nino and his family has arrived, in fact, their servant Maria’s son Panchito has disappeared in the jungle, never to return, obviously a sinful boy who the monster has spirited off. Understandably, Ernesto declares the jungle, with its snakes, falling trees, and legendary spirits, off limits.

      Obviously such a declaration makes trips to the jungle necessary for a confused young man, unable to comprehend his urges and terrified for what they represent. The more he is preached to, the more his adolescent hormones rebel, and even the naked Christ of the cross becomes a masturbatory icon.

       Free from these tensions, so it seems, are the hypocrisies of Nino sister and her parents. Her sister, a few years older, and her friends are exploring lesbian sex with one another until Natalia begins sneaking off for heterosexual sex with one of her father’s beefy workers.


      The gentle worker, Malevo (Beto Frágola) is asked to help her fix the living room fan and other tasks, with a growing sexual tension between the two emanating particularly from Estela, since her husband is off for days in jungle on jobs.

       Hearing of the legend of Almamula, Nino pulls out a painting his grandmother once did of the terrifying figure and posts first a crucifix and later the painting on a jungle tree, demanding that one or the other fetch him and take him away from the isolated world he now inhabits, and where even the slightest of infractions (masturbation itself seen as sin by the priest and church) are punishable in one form or another. For a boy having homosexual feelings on top of his normal teenage sexual angst, it is nearly unbearable.

      At one point, Malevo summons him out of room, and pulls him into the jungle to jack him off. Nino is rightfully horrified, but also aroused and more than a little interested in the man who seems so fearless in a society of moral hypocrisy. And over the course of the film Malevo becomes a kind of mentor to the boy, taking him in more as a friend than as a pedophilic object when Nino most needs it.

     Yet, as reviewer Jennie Kermode observed in Eye for Film:

 

“It is men like this whom he fantasies about in scenes which may inspire concern in viewers, because he is still a child, and for all we know, one of them may have taken Panchito. Whilst the church community may think it is protecting the boy, his inability to talk to anybody about his desires makes him very vulnerable. It’s a lonely, difficult coming of age, and one which gradually leads him to identify with the otherness of the forest—a place which is also under threat.”

 

     Although director Torales hints at supernatural forces in the jungle, and occasionally Nino hears a sound or glimpses of what seems to be a running figure, the film stays very much within the realm of naturalism. Indeed, the most horrific and shocking moment of the movie comes when Nino enters a clearing only to see his father and the loggers dressed in masks, their faces chalk-white from the dust of tree bark standing, like ghouls, alongside the gigantic machines which are raping the woods. The church says nothing about this immoral action, choosing to focus instead on the genitals of 12-year-old boys.

     When in confession, Nino admits to his fantasies of the naked Christ, he is immediately dragged off to a shed and locked away, his mother called. She, in turn, is distressed than her son only seems to be growing worse, blaming her husband for not being father who was there for him.


     Despite returning to a few days of normalcy, the child goes missing again, this time hanging out with Malevo by the nearby ocean inlets where he fishes with other men of the area, their only source of healthy food.

     Brought home again, and put to work among his father’s loggers as punishment, he asks the maid María what her son Panchito had done that was so awful that he needed to be sent away. Her answer is only that Nino has not sinned enough.

     By this time, however, we have come to realize that perhaps the only truly innocent figure in this film is Nino in his search for his honest feelings, while others all pretend piety but fornicate, cheat, terrorize, and destroy under the cover of their moral pretenses. If this Argentinian Babadook actually comes for Nino, it will surely be to protect the saintly sinner instead of destroy him.


     Forced, finally, to participate in the confirmation exercises, Nino once more walks off the moment the ceremony his over, checking under the loincloth of the huge Christ her mother has had carved for the occasion before eventually wandering back into the jungle.


    There, for the first time, he observes in the near distance a figure, a young boy like him, with sunlight streaming down upon him. Is it Panchito come back just for him, a vision, a hallucination, a fantasy of someone, like himself, with whom in the future he can feel safe? No answer is given. It is up for each of us, as it is for Nino, to make meaning of things out of the time and space in which one is temporarily trapped.

       The situation calls up two previous opposing cinematic possibilities: Alan Clarke’s highly spiritual and almost nationalistically mystical Penda’s Fen (1974) or the far more realistic movie, although magical in its own way, Fuoco Maria Balduzzi Wolves (2016). Neither seems quite appropriate, but if I had to choose I’d have it go in a direction closer to the Balduzzi film, the boys living happily in a wilderness of their innocent love.

 

Los Angeles, July 24, 2023

Reprinted from World Cinema Review (July 2023).

 

Irvin Winkler | De-Lovely / 2004

under our skin

by Douglas Messerli

 

Jay Cocks (screenplay), Irvin Winkler (director) De-Lovely / 2004

 

I’ve got you under my skin.

I’ve got you deep in the heart of me.

So deep in my heart that you’re really part of me.

I’ve got you under my skin.

 

Perhaps the most underrated movie of 2004 was Irvin Winkler’s De-Lovely, a movie devoted to the life of Cole Porter. Manohla Dargis, writing in the Los Angeles Times, began her review by describing the movie as “De-Lousy” and The New York Times reviewer Stephen Holden wondered if Porter could have survived “a movie so lifeless and drained of genuine joie de vivre it makes you long for the largely fictional earlier film” on his life. Desson Thomson of The Washington Post saw the movie as unable to overcome its own “stagy conceit.”

     My companion and I, however, quite liked the picture, and Howard went back to see it several times. The Polish film director Zbigniew Kaminski, who lives in our building, agreed with me that it was one of the better films of the year. My poet friend Charles Bernstein, moreover, reported that he had also enjoyed it, particularly actor Kevin Kline’s musical renditions, which reminded him of Porter’s own high, whining voice.


     What I enjoyed about this film was what Thomson had described as “stagy,” the theatricality of it. As I’ve noted elsewhere in these queer essays, Americans are true literalists: we like our theater, particularly when filmed, to be true-to-life, whatever that might mean. And we are quite intolerant, as many critics of this film were, with songs interpreted in new ways. In that sense, any film of the larger than-life Porter might have been impossible. For, like British composer and dramatist Nöel Coward, Porter lived a life that was a highly stylized, one largely invented in his own creative imagination.


     Accordingly, I liked the conceit of presenting Porter’s history as a theatrical event, beginning with the isolated figure of the composer playing “In the Still of the Night” and quickly shifting to the presentation of his friends and “cast” in “Anything Goes.” This musical theater motif, continuing with Kevin Kline and Kevin McNally (as Porter’s artist friend Gerald Murphy) performing “Well Did You Evah!” at a party where Porter meets Linda Lee, his future wife, is followed, soon after, with Kline’s charming rendition of “Easy to Love.” Perhaps the best moment of Winkler’s fluid cinematic maneuvering occurs in the next scene as Porter begins singing his newest song, “What Is This Thing Called Love?” to Irving Berlin and his wife, the tune picked up and sung more gloriously by a gondolier (the singer Lemur) as he passes the Porter’s Venice mansion, the Palazzo Ca’Rezzonico.

     No matter that according to William McBrien’s biography of the composer, Porter actually met his future wife in 1918 at a wedding between Ethel Harriman and Henry Russell, while “Well Did You Evah! was composed for the musical DuBarry Was a Lady in 1940; or that Porter wrote “Easy to Love” in the 1930s, and that he had already met Irving Berlin in New York in the early 1920s several years before “What Is This Thing Called Love?” was written! As long as the director presents the movie as a musical fantasy, the film is quite enchanting. Similarly, it matters little to me that some of the unlikely performers of the songs in this film were not quite suited to some of the works, particularly Alanis Morisette in her rendition of “Let’s Do It, Let’s Fall in Love” and Sheryl Crow in “Begin the Beguine.” These less than perfect performances merely confirm how adaptable Porter’s music and lyrics truly are, how much they have gotten “under our [collective] skin.”


     This is not to say that De-Lovely is necessarily a successful film. For me, it begins to fail when it forgets its theatrical conventions, shifting the focus to Porter’s relationship with his wife. Despite the seemingly “honest” depictions in this film of Porter’s homosexuality, the film is oddly prudish when it approaches the subject of Linda Porter. At its heart, the film seems to argue that, despite Porter’s true love for Linda, he treated her so rottenly that the relationship was doomed, and that, even though she often “accepted” his male companions, Porter’s increasingly flagrant public behavior was their ruination. In short, if Winkler’s direction begins by taking the movie down the path of Porter’s own musical fantasies, Jay Cock’s script increasingly centers it on what the author perceives as the composer’s sexual failures, a story that comes dangerously close to being homophobic.

     I suppose the filmmakers simply felt that the American public would not be able to accept the fact that Linda Porter was a wealthy socialite whose friends included many lesbians, and that it was she, for example, who introduced Cole to Diaghilev and, perhaps, even to Diaghilev’s lover Boris Kochno—not the other way around.

     In a story that attempts to focus its sympathies on the “wronged woman,” it may be dramatically appealing to present Linda’s respiratory illness at a time when she had decided to end her relationship with her husband; but in reality she was in ill health throughout much of her life, and was diagnosed with serious health problems as early as the 1920s.

     There is no doubt that Porter often treated Linda badly and that, despite her tolerance for his affairs, she felt ignored and kept at a remove from him and his daily activities. But she too, in part because of bad health, perhaps in retaliation, and, one might conjecture, out of her own personal interests, spent long periods away from him. Although the film hints at some of these issues, it spends a great deal more time concentrating on Porter’s outrageous sexual outings with male prostitutes in Hollywood—where “love” is “for sale”—in opposition to the more stable and conventional relationship of his friends such as the Murphys.


     Except for presenting the early affair with Kochno, Porter’s lifelong friendship with Monte Woolley, his brief liaison with an actor named Jack (John Barrowman) to whom actor Kline brilliantly sings “Night and Day,” and a late-life relationship with a character the movie names Bill Wrather, supposedly Linda’s interior decorator with whom she “arranges” a relationship with Cole (a figure seemingly based on Porter’s friend John Cronin, who insisted he had no sexual relationship with Porter), there is little attempt in Cock’s story to explore the many longer-termed homosexual relationships between Porter and Eddy Tauch, Nelson Barclift, and others that occurred throughout his life, and may have been just as influential and meaningful to his music as his marriage. If the earlier film Night and Day mythologized the love between Cole and Linda, this film almost demonizes it.

     What might have worked better, I would argue, is the more fantastical telling of Porter’s life with which the movie began and which sporadically reappears, as in the number “Be a Clown,” satirizing Louis B. Mayer. Porter was an almost archetypal American Midwesterner in love with European aristocracy and wealth, passions which, when mixed with sexual desires unacceptable in American society, forced him—and his wife as well—to create a world apart from that in which they might have more normally lived: a world parallel to, but removed from the “real” context of ordinary people. However, it may have been that very distancing that allowed Porter to compose such extraordinary music and lyrics; writing always at the edge of American sexual and social consciousness, he could burrow under the skin of our desires in way that no “ordinary” American composer might. Like Gatsby, Porter lived in a glamorous world of fantasy from where he could observe, as Gatsby secretly observed his guests, that behind the American façade there were other passions “deep in [our] hearts” which were “really a part of [him].”

 

Los Angeles, August 19, 2004

Reprinted from Green Integer Review (2004).

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Liam Wesson | Lion / 2017

how to come out

by Douglas Messerli

 

Liam Wesson (screenwriter and director) Lion / 2017 [15 minutes]

 

British director Liam Wesson’s short film Lion reads pretty much as an instructional and inspirational film about coming out as a gay man.

    A reclusive country lad, Tom (Jack McBride) is checking out things on line on his ChatLad, but has not yet come out, and he’s terrified of having to confront his younger brother Kieron (Liam Wesson).

    Yet finally, on this particular night, he makes a date at the local bar with someone named George (David Parry). After a great deal of confusion about what to wear, he finally chooses a suitable outfit, but can’t yet even bring himself to cross the road and enter the Lion Bar & Club. He finally does so, snuggling up to the bar for a dark beer.


    In another part of the room sits a man in drag, chatting up some younger customers. Spotting the young newcomer, the drag queen, much to his consternation, comes over and begins to tease the handsome newcomer. When she finally makes an exit, Tom takes to the street for a smoke, the drag queen soon joining him. She finally introduces herself as George, Tom startled by the discovery, but still willing, upon her request, to buy her a drink.

     As they stand out in the back yard of the bar drinking, George points out a young man who has been eyeing Tom, while attempting to relax the most uncomfortable young Tom, who suggests that perhaps he shouldn’t have, that he feels unsure whether or not he really fits in. George explains that no gay person feels that they do fit in the first time; that he really has to take it one day at a time. She also provides him with a brief history of how difficult it was to be gay in her day, and naming several of the British heroes who made things different, including Peter Wild Blood, Mark Ashton, Alan Turing, and her young friend, who was attacked by a gang one night who played a game of tick-tack-toe on his back with knives.



     Finally, Tom does approach the stranger (Dan Edwards) and two quickly make friends, drinking, dancing, and talking, Tom going on for a rather long time about his fears that although

gays have been granted marriage and things have changed, he worries that it might again become worse, especially with people in the world like the US President Trump.

     Meanwhile, his brother Kieron meets up with his girlfriend, Chrissie (Moureen Louie) at an art gallery. There he tells her that he thinks that Tom has, for the one of the very first time, gone out for the night, and wonders aloud whether he might be queer? Chrissie is furious with him not only for using the word but for suggesting something that he has knowledge about.

     But when they too enter the Lion Bar for a night out, they immediately spot Tom dancing, and call over to him. Spotting them, Tom runs out of the bar and returns home, Kieran following and entering his room. Tom begs him to not even have him explain it, to say who he is, but Kieran sits down on the bed and hugs him, assuring that to him it makes no difference whatsoever, and that he is loved.

    David Parry is really quite excellent as George, the drag queen, but I wish she might have been given a speech just a little less oriented to a lesson in how to come out. Yet one can hardly dislike any movie that helps individuals take that difficult step. There’s nothing really wrong with this film, it’s just clumsily handled with a defter director might have made far more engaging.

 

Los Angeles, November 17, 2026

Reprinted from My Queer Cinema blog (November 2026).

 

  

Monday, November 16, 2026

Taran Killam | Fanatic / 2023

deep inside

by Douglas Messerli

 

Andrew Chappelle (screenplay, based on story by Chappelle and Mike Millan), Taran Killam (director) Fanatic / 2023 [16 minutes]

 

A truly silly, campy, musical satire in which the central characters, Charlie Trasche (Andrew Chappelle) and Gerald (Devere Rogers), work at a donut shop when Charlie isn’t taping videos of old gay men getting it on by hugging him close as they throw him into a dumpster, Fanatic is so frenetic that the viewer hardly has time to assimilate the corny jokes it tosses off as asides.

      Approached by a woman, Clista (Shannon Dang), who wants them to appear with boybands of the past in a competition, they both reject her. But when she reports the winner gets not only to   tour, but $20,000 in cold hard cash, they concur with any producer who chooses to cast Jennifer Hudson, “What have we got to lose?”  If they win, Charlie quips, he won’t have to sell his blood to Armie Hammer anymore. “For the love of Timothy Chalamet,” please, pleads Charlie let’s try it. (I quote these comments so, like me, you can truly treasure the level of the humor of this work.)


      So “2n1,” the name of their old boy band is reborn, as they work out and create a new set of dances, costumes, and makeup, reviving their long-forgotten hit song, the pedophilic “Daddy’s Boy.” Even they have little hopes of winning, going up against such groups as “Vegan Timeless” (formerly “Boy’s Time”) and “IBS” (“International Boy’s Sound”) starring Trevor (Matt Cook), but they certainly give it their best.

      The most charming moment of this movie is their actual performance, a hilarious tribute to their “No. 1 Daddy”: “Be my father, figure me out,” “I feel you deep inside of me, please don’t be absentee,” “I’m par-ty-ing, par-ty-ing with my legal guardian,” “There’s a daddy inside all of us or is it only me?”—a song perhaps created in honor of their former manager who forced them to tattoo his name on their butts and demanded they stay after every show and shower with him. Not surprisingly, most of the audience sits in startled silence.


       Shockingly, they win, seemingly good news until they discover that the contest was fixed by a former fan, “fanatic” Melissa (Caroline Rhea), who waiting in vain after every performance for them (while they were showering with Daddy), now wants to have them to finally sign her program—which incidentally contains the contract which states she has complete control of their lives as their new manager. She awards them the $20,000 in Kohl’s Card Cash, not “cold hard cash” as they were led to believe.

       Refusing to repeat their horrific past, they tear up the contract and start to head back to the donut shop. Only this time there are real fans waiting outside the theater door. Oh bliss!  They both go skipping down the street.

       At least they now know, deep inside, they had some small talent.

 

Los Angeles, July 23, 2023 | Reprinted from World Cinema Review (July 2023).

Caio Scot | Depois Daquela Festa (After That Party) / 2019

can we talk?

by Douglas Messerli

 

Mel Carvalho and Lucas Drummond (screenplay), Caio Scot (director) Depois Daquela Festa (After That Party) / 2019 [15 minutes]

 

Of the dozen films I discuss in the collection of essays, “Family Secrets,” Brazilian director Caio Scot’s After that Party is the only truly comic presentation of family sexual secrets, reflecting as it does a far more contemporary viewpoint which we hope now dominates open societies.       

     This story is really quite simple. Leo (Lucas Drummond) and his long-time girlfriend (Mel Carvalho)—with whom, oddly since it has no reason to appear in this tale except as a kind of quirky aside, he evidently doesn’t have sex—attend a party at which, quite by accident, they both witness Leo’s father (Charles Fricks) in attendance kissing another man.      

   The shock of the scene momentarily sends Leo reeling, having to leave the party immediately to contemplate the situation. His girlfriend pushes him quickly to try to express his true feeling about the incident, and it appears that he is not so upset because he has discovered that his widowed father is now gay, but that he hasn’t told him. The two, father and son, have long been close, and Leo still lives at home with his dad.



       Although the discovery does not seem to be particularly momentous with regard to his love for his father, he and his girlfriend feel it necessary to relieve his father of his secret by revealing their new awareness of the situation. The question is simply how to go about it, and Leo spends a sleepless night in creating a scenario over a meal of lasagna where he might bring up the subject by discussing his father’s job as an advertising executive before turning it to a discussion of his friends, their off-hour activities, and whether or not he meets others outside of his co-workers, etc. until he can zero in on the particularities which might lead to the revelation.

      Unfortunately, his father serves stroganoff, not their usual Friday night meal, and their conversation is interrupted by a telephone message before it can even begin.


    A day or two later Leo finally confronts his father by recalling a childhood story about himself in which he was afraid of asking his teacher permission to go to the bathroom, as a consequence peeing in his pants and receiving the taunts of his fellow students, all resulting in his determination never to return to school. His father reassured him that he had done nothing wrong, and to prove that he needed to return to the classroom to assert his innocence of wrongdoing.

      So too, he now suggests, he argues his father needn’t feel that he has done anything wrong in the fact that the son has witnessed at the very same party that Leo and his girlfriend attended, his father embrace and kiss a stranger.

      For a moment the father attempts to deny it, but quickly becomes speechless. When he regains his composure, he explains that he never cheated or lied to Leo’s mother and loved her dearly. But suddenly he has found an unexpected love with another human being who just happens to be a man. But there was simply no way he could explain it to Leo for fear that he would misunderstand the situation. 


     When it is now established that Leo has no problems with him now having a “boyfriend,” the two hug, the elder realizing that there was no need for secrecy, that he was deeply loved and remains so. Leo insists that the three of them have dinner so that can, he jokes, “determine his intentions” regarding his dad.

      Scot’s film feels a little too much like a liberal school-room advocation of open minds and free talk about sexuality. But the script, written by the two actors playing Leo and his girlfriend, at moments is delightfully manic in the son’s attempts to arrange for that open and free conversation between father and son, resulting in Scot’s work being a lot of fun, even if we know the final “feel-good” results. Surely there are a great many Leos and dads out there who have been shaped, post Stonewall, by the general acceptance of LGBTQ behavior in liberal societies worldwide. But, alas, I am afraid that they still do not represent the majority of households. On the very same day I am writing about this film, I have also just watched director/producer Aiman Hasani’s Dutch film Khata (2019) in which a couple of teenage brothers, trapped into male prostitution and with nowhere else to turn, are denied entry into the own home by their parents upon their discovery of their boys’ secret vocations, which only closes off their final possible route of escape. Indeed, this film might also have been included in these pages except that I felt it was more centered on their involvement in gay prostitution which I will feature in an upcoming essay, “Working Boys.”

     But it’s a delight to watch a work in which family secrets do not necessarily result in terrifying consequences.

 

Los Angeles, September 21, 2021

Reprinted from World Cinema Review (September 2021).

 

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Keisuke Kinoshita | 惜春鳥 (Farewell to Spring) / 1959

old friends drifting apart

by Douglas Messerli

 

Keisuke Kinoshita (screenwriter and director) 惜春鳥 (Farewell to Spring) / 1959

 

Japanese homosexual director Keisuke Kinoshita’s 1959 masterful film, Farewell to Spring is often mentioned by critics as Japan’s first gay movie, although as Sekenbanashi, writing in 2019 in Theater Reviews: Tokyo, NY, London observes “but that definition would have to be stretched fairly liberally.”

     First of all, there were a number of far more openly gay films or at least homoerotic works in Japanese cinematic history before that time, including Tomu Uchida’s Keisatsukan (Policeman) of 1933, which quite openly reveals that he and his now gangster friend had a very close and loving relationship in their college days, as well as Yasujirō Ozu’s Dragnet Girl of the very same year. Those works later inspired the noir homoerotic thriller, Kurosawa’s Stray Dog (1949). Ozu films such as Late Spring (1949) and Early Summer (1951) have also been put forth by some critics as having possible lesbian or at least sexually ambiguous female relationships. And the 1952 Kurosawa film, To Live (1952), has scenes in which a novelist takes the major figure on a night journey through regular geisha parlors and even obvious gay bars to help ease his suffering. And there are other works as well, all before 1959. One year before Kinoshita’s work, Kon Ichikawa had hinted at homosexual longings in his film Conflagration, with a script by gay writer Yukio Mishima.  Even Kinoshita’s own 1951 film, Fireworks Over the Sea features a young boy who has, at least metaphorically, “fallen in love” with or, if nothing else, acquired a queer admiration for an older man which, as critic Eric Guo puts it, reminds him “of the first time I became aware of my own attraction to men.”

     Almost all critics, moreover, have been far more reticence to recognize the gay scenes in Kinoshita’s film. Hemming-and-hawing their way through the earliest scene without fully discussing the views and attitudes strongly suggested by the members of this bittersweet get-together of five high-school friends in their hometown of Aizu. These are, in fact, not at all coded clues to the already highly homosocially-bonded young men, but open, if subtle references of actual or perceived homosexual friendships of the past, some of which have clearly carried over into the present.


                                          Studio Promotion Photo:Yusuke Kawazu (front, left) and Mashiko Tsugawa (front, center)

   In order to perceive these relationships, however, one must quickly pick up the names of the various characters who gather at an inn run by one of their member’s family, Minemura (Kazuya Kosaka). The inn, formerly a geisha house, has run on hard times these days because of the new 1956 prostitution laws. Certainly, they have room for the one out-of-town guest, Naoji Iwagaki (Yusuke Kawazu), returned after two years of college in Tokyo. All his other friends have remained in the provincial city in which they grew up.

     On the train before his arrival, moreover, in runs into the uncle of his best friend from high Yasuo Makita. The uncle, Eitaro Makita (Keiji Sada), has now a reputation for having run off and eloped with one of the geishas, Midori (Ineko Arima), now working again in the inn where she is debt-bonded, an issue which becomes important in many ways in this film. The uncle, Eitaro, now sick with tuberculosis and tired of life in general, is returning to his sister’s inn to die. She cannot even be bothered to call a doctor.

     Iwagaki has his own shame to bear. Having evidently become involved with a maid in Tokyo, he has been shamed and fallen out of favor with his major supporter and former professor, and is now having to find a way to pay for his education himself. We’ll come back to those issues later.

     The first few moments of Iwagaki’s arrival to the inn reveal, in fact, some of the most potent moments of homosocial bonding. As they sit before Iwagaki even fully removes his outer clothing, Inagaki takes his friend Minemura’s hands, looking deep into his eyes and explaining how much he has missed him. The two then immediately retreat to the hot tub, where they share in singing one of their high-school songs.


     Soon after, Akira Masugi (Toyozo Yamamoto) and Kozo Teshirogi (Akira Ishihama) arrive, the servant explaining that their two friends are taking a bath. We notice immediately that Masugi has a bad leg, limping his way up the steps (as he puts it in the terrible terms of the late 1950s, he’s a “gimp.”). The handsome Teshirogi is simply a presence in the room, whom soon fills the space with his sense of class hierarchy. 

     Even before they enter their rooms, Masugi rushes to the bathhouse to observe his two friends half-naked, rushing over and quite literally hugging and kissing Iwagaki, both explaining how very much they have missed one another. This statement is far more deeply-felt and sensational that Iwagaki’s earlier admission of his friendship to Minemura, and we recognize almost immediately that there is a spark of a very special emotional bond between these two young men. The smiles on their faces alone attest to a truly genuine bond that we soon discover goes beyond the mere homosocial bonding that each of the other’s have.

     Meanwhile, Teshirogi, announces to the servant that he is paying not only for the room but for the food and service. He orders up three geisha to join them at their dinner that evening.

      Because of bullying and other reasons, we later discover, Masugi has not even been able to finish high school, being protected all those years by Iwagaki, who stood up against the bullying against his friend. The other friends later even insinuate that they always presumed there was some kind of homosexual relationship between the two. If nothing else they have long assumed, although never openly spoken about it, that Masugi is gay.


    Commentators have made it clear that as an already physically-challenged male due to an accident in his youth, Masugi has not been able to participate in their male rituals such as we shall later see in their rendition of the essential dance to the Byakkotai (White Tiger Forces), soldiers of Aizu who in the 19th century mistakenly came to the conclusion that their lord’s castle had fallen and together committed hara-kiri rather than submit to their enemy. The other four enact their version of the dance while Masugi recites, interspersed by scenes of a more traditional performance, making it clear that this story is one of the central forces in their homosocial bond, played out in the performance with mock swords.


    Because of his weaker position, Masugi is an easy target for Teshirogi’s barbed comment quietly mocking Masugi’s affection for Iwagaki that he hints runs beyond mere friendship. Yet the comment, ignored by the others, is likely true, since of all the men, Masugi alone seems to have no involvement with women. He works at home devoted with his family to one of the other “treasures” of Aizu, the famed lacquerwork paintings of dishware.

    Teshirogi, however, has no real reason to lord himself above the others as he does. Although his family comes from samurai stock, as his family’s second son he is now an impoverished factory worker, working evidently at his father’s company, but himself involved as an activist in the labor movement. Yet Teshirogi definitely exudes a sense of class superiority throughout the work.

    During their visit to the graves of the White Tiger Force sword dance, Iwagaki finally explains why he was abandoned in his education by their favorite high school teacher. He did not at all love the maid, who did none of her duties, but hated her for her mockery of his behavior and his Aizu accent. In a sense she treated him somewhat like the boys at school treated his friend Masugi. But in a strange act, which he appears to see as justified, he finally rapes her as punishment for her behavior, and now despite her pleas for him to stay, he quickly leaves her. Throughout his confession, Masugi is loud in his attempts to stop his friend from admitting his acts; but Iwagaki continues, all of other four men refusing to make comment on his behavior.


     Perhaps the reason critics have difficulty in truly embracing this as a fully gay film, moreover, is because after these moments, Kinoshita shifts the entire focus of his film, directing our attention to a brewing struggle between the haughty Teshirogi and Iwagaki’s friend Makita, the illegitimate son of a bar owner who is being primed to take over the family business. Makita and the Minemura servant Yoko (Yukiyo Toake), who is the niece of Makita’s biological father, a now rather wealthy pawnbroker with a gorgon of a wife, Tane (Teruko Kishi) who understandably hates Mikita’s mother. Mistress and wife battle over Yoko. It might be good, actually, for Makita to marry into the family offering his father an heir; but Makita’s mother, determined that he take over the bar and Tane’s refusal to have her mistress’ own son live under her roof, rules, and both father and mother insist that Yoko marry into a family of supposed nobility such as the Teshirogi clan.

    Teshirogi’s father and Makita’s father agree to the marriage, although the highly modernized Yoko wants nothing to do with their decision. Given the “cold” situation in which he has grown up, however, Makita has acquired a great sense of the futility to fix such situations, particularly given the history of his own uncle, who having run off with Midori, could only watch as she was fetched back to serve out her debt. In a sense, Makita, because of his illegitimacy, finds himself in a similar place, in debt to his own mother and father without the possibility of escaping.

     A meeting between Teshirogi and Yoko is arranged, but even there she asks for permission to speak alone with her would-be husband, demanding in no uncertain terms that he reject her since she has absolutely no intentions of marrying him even if he means she will have to live alone. Teshirogi returns alone to the meeting of the fathers and Tane, answering that he will answer soon through his own father. Meanwhile the group is told that Yoko has left.

     In his one instance in which he appears to live up to the brotherly bond supposedly involving these men, Teshirogi seeks out Makita to wonder how he might feel if he were to marry Yoko, which would mean wealth for the impoverished factory worker. Makita is so diffident in his response, despite what we know is still a real love for Yoko, that Teshirogi reads it as permission and acts accordingly, announcing that he will marry the girl. Besides, he admits, despite his own conservative demeanor, he likes the spirited young woman.

     But Kinoshita has yet other plot developments that again shift the action. During all this time Iwagaki has begun to act strangely, asking Teshirogi for a loan, and Mikita to place an old camera he has in his possession in father’s pawn shop; Mikita pays him outright for the meaningless machine. He approaches others for loans, even his old friend Masugi. Masugi asks his mother for the money which she gives him, although unable to comprehend why he is so willing to help out Iwagaki. Iwagaki personally asks Makita to buy an old scroll from him. What becomes apparent is that Iwagaki has evidently borrowed money in order to continue his education, and now must pay it back to the man or group who he owes it, finally having evidently raised enough to meet him at the train station and leave Aizu on the next train out.

     Makita’s pawnbroker father, in the meantime, has been approached by the police regarding Iwagaki’s fraud. Moreover, when Minemura discovers that his own Rolex watch has been stolen, the “friends” are forced to encounter and challenge Iwagaki about his actions, he reporting that he is on his way to take the train away from their lives forever, but not before returning the watch and a scarf he has stolen.

      Despite all the bonds of friendship, however, Teshirogi determines to call the police and report that Iwagaki, the thief, is on his way to the station, despite both Minemura’s and Masugi’s attempts to stop him.


     In one more plot twist, Makita has illicitly arranged to have his uncle meet with his geisha lover Midori. At first, the older man refuses, while Makita keeps insisting that it would be far better than simply giving into death. At one point he offers up the scroll he has purchased from Iwagaki to his uncle, which unscrolled shows one of the famous of all Japanese prints of a geisha and her lover. Still the elder Makita keeps resisting until finally he is noticed missing, obviously gone off to spend the day with his beloved.

     At the very same moment that Teshirogi makes the call to have Iwagaki arrested, Makita hears that news that his uncle and Midori have committed a double suicide in the snow near the gravesites of the White Tiger Forces. His friends insist he go to the death site of his uncle immediately. Masugi, however, is determined to warn his friend before he gets to the station, and against custom Makita insists he will join his him, the two arriving too late, however, to save their friend from arrestment. Just to watch the desperate attempts of the lame man to reach the station reveal a love far deeper that any of the others have represented in their empty and sarcastic acts. Despite all the betrayal’s of Iwagaki, it is clear that Masugi is still very much in love and willing to risk whatever he has to save his friend.

    Utterly furious with Teshirogi for his behavior, the weaker Masugi challenges him to a fighting duel the next day. When his other friends, hear of the challenge they rush off the save Masugi from being beaten, Makita now newly energized by his uncle’s and Midori’s example is suddenly willing himself to fight for Yoko’s love.

    So love is redeemed in this truly open-hearted work of cinema, even if only Masugi, Minemura, and possibly Makita have lived up to the band’s early ideals. And while, Kinoshita’s film was not the first Japanese gay film, it was one of the sincerest, as modestly and restrained as he presented it.

 

Los Angeles, November 15, 2026

Reprinted from My Queer Cinema blog (November 2026).        



Titles Index A-N

https://myqueercinema.blogspot.com/2023/12/former-index-to-world-cinema-review.html Films discussed (listed alphabetically by director) [F...